The WORST episodes of St. Elsewhere

Every episode of St. Elsewhere ever, ranked from worst to best by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The worst episodes of St. Elsewhere!

St. Eligius Hospital in South Boston was not exactly the world's best health care center. Despite its flaws, it featured some of the most caring doctors and nurses you could ever meet. Led by Dr. Donald Westphall (and later by Dr. John Gideon), the hospital nicknamed "St. Elsewhere" became a sanctuary for the underdog and the downtrodden.

Last Updated: 9/18/2024Network: NBCStatus: Ended
star
5.00
5 votes

#1 - Good Vibrations

Season 5 - Episode 21 - Aired 5/13/1987

The representative of a foreign medical group interested in the hospital visits to absorb the psychic `aura' of the place (via flashbacks) but collapses from a heart attack before he can recommend the sale.

Directors: Bruce Paltrow
star
6.71
7 votes

#2 - Visiting Daze

Season 5 - Episode 14 - Aired 1/21/1987

Axelrod allows Novino and Griffin to override his judgement; Dr. Kiem worries about her long distance marriage as she tries to help an inseparable couple make a final farewell; Luther tries to help Polly make it through a day without her medication; and Ehrlich goes to great lengths to confirm the Oseranskys' story.

star
6.80
5 votes

#3 - Russian Roulette

Season 5 - Episode 13 - Aired 1/14/1987

Dr. Craig becomes jealous when Dr. Peltrovich is finally allowed to pursue his work with lasers; Fiscus experiences an emotional rollercoaster as he returns to work with a critical leukemia patient; and Ehrlich hits highs and lows as he accepts his ""Orphan of the Year"" award.

star
6.88
8 votes

#4 - Brand New Bag

Season 5 - Episode 4 - Aired 10/15/1986

The Craigs try out yet another new maid; fellow employees stab Luther in the back; Axelrod is embarrassed and rude about a patient's colostomy; and Fiscus helps Mr. Ewell's daughter take him home to die.

star
7.00
9 votes

#5 - Heart On

Season 6 - Episode 8 - Aired 11/18/1987

Craig proceeds with his artificial heart implant despite some questions about his choice of candidates; Morrison tries to deal with the departure of Joanne for Seattle and Dr. Craig becomes suspicious about the relationship between Ellen and Dr. Gideon. AIDS patient, Brett Johnston, and his lover are victims of gay bashingan and as a result of his injuries, Brett is readmitted into the hospital.

Directors: Michael Fresco
star
7.00
8 votes

#6 - Up and Down

Season 5 - Episode 7 - Aired 11/12/1986

Lizzie gets involved with Griffin; a man falls while trying to scale the hospital; Luther befriends a bag lady with Tourette's Syndrome; and John Doe #6 disappears with Dr. Craig's book.

star
7.00
7 votes

#7 - The Boom Boom Womb

Season 4 - Episode 12 - Aired 1/8/1986

An anti-abortionist targets the hospital for bomb threats and Chandler is involved in trouble at the Boston Women's Clinic; Rosenthal decides what she must do with her youngest son; Luther loses his favorite racing pigeon, whom he left in Axelrod's care; and Morrison tries to explain abortion to Pru. Dr. Westphall's housekeeper has her INS hearing. Mona and Wayne quarrel.

star
7.13
8 votes

#8 - Once Upon a Mattress

Season 5 - Episode 10 - Aired 12/3/1986

Fiscus awakens but is deeply depressed, despite a visit from his father; Dr. Craig returns to work and his office, disregarding Dr. Kiem's feelings; Dr. Westphall decides to stop seeing Novino and his moving man comes in for a penile implant.

star
7.13
8 votes

#9 - To Tell the Truth

Season 4 - Episode 13 - Aired 1/15/1986

Fiscus reluctantly does his outreach work with a couple of feisty old people; Chandler is near yet another explosion; John Doe #6 is claimed by a couple who seem as wacky as he is; Rosenthal and Papandrao settle out of court; and the Valeres consider adoption and divorce as they come to the medical end of the line for their fertility problem.

Writer: Steve Lawson
star
7.13
8 votes

#10 - Haunted

Season 4 - Episode 3 - Aired 10/23/1985

The Craigs face a tremendous loss as their first grandchild is born; a newly inspired Dr. Westphall returns to work full of ideas; and Fiscus invites himself up to Dr. Caldwell's Cape Cod retreat, where he sees a different side to the surgeon. Elliot and Marcy discover a common interest in food.

star
7.17
6 votes

#11 - The Abby Singer Show

Season 6 - Episode 21 - Aired 5/18/1988

An ebullient Novino pursues Morrison; Fiscus tries to revitalize his mother's life; Rosenthal returns to duty; Wade tries to help a dying child deal with her bitterly divided parents; Griffin tests positive for AIDS; Dr. Turner returns and helps Chandler come to a decision about his future; and the Oseranskys return to take Lucy to the ""Doctor of the Year"" dinner, which ends in a flaming disaster.

Writer: Tom Fontana
star
7.17
6 votes

#12 - Split Decision

Season 6 - Episode 20 - Aired 5/11/1988

Brett Johnston's parents come to visit; even in death Axelrod doesn't get any respect; Rosenthal waits for her release while her roommate runs away; Luther proposes to Penny; and Dr. Craig returns to St. Eligius to do a multiple transplant.

Writer: Aram Saroyan
star
7.17
6 votes

#13 - Heaven's Skate

Season 6 - Episode 13 - Aired 1/13/1988

Judge Farnham checks into the hospital with an inoperable cancer (and asking for Floyd the Barber); Rosenthal takes Bobby Caldwell's death very hard; Dr. Craig searches for a date for a skating rink opening; Dr. Kiem is in the middle when she saves the life of a young black man shot by a Vietnamese gang member; Griffin befriends the new chaplain, who's a descendant of the hospital founder, Father McCabe; Novino and Luther compete on the ER simulator and Ehrlich tries to find his elusive parents.

Writer: Ann Reckling
star
7.20
10 votes

#14 - Resurrection

Season 6 - Episode 1 - Aired 9/16/1987

One month after St. Eligius was shut down, it is reopened by The Ecumena Corporation and its head of medicine Dr. John Gideon. Meanwhile, Dr. Craig is offered the opportunity to design an artificial heart, which the younger doctors jokingly call the ""Craig 5000.""

Directors: Bruce Paltrow
star
7.25
8 votes

#15 - A Room With a View

Season 5 - Episode 3 - Aired 10/8/1986

Dr. Craig behaves boorishly to his replacement, Dr. Paulette Kiem; Birch finds a radioactive patient; Papandrao claims Ehrlich as an escort to a family birthday party; a friend of Fiscus' is admitted with a major stroke; and a hospital neighbor becomes very upset when she observes Dr. Craig's imminent departure.

star
7.25
8 votes

#16 - Lost Weekend

Season 5 - Episode 11 - Aired 12/10/1986

Dr. Westphall tries to help an alcoholic poet he once admired; Dr. Craig puts his usual worst foot forward as he tries to persuade the Soviets to release Masha's husband; Rosenthal confronts McPhail about her drug problem; and Ehrlich makes friends with Papandrao's new boyfriend.

Directors: Eric Laneuville
star
7.29
7 votes

#17 - Their Town

Season 6 - Episode 17 - Aired 4/20/1988

Dr. Craig, Ellen, Lizzie and Novino drive to Peterborough, New Hampshire to visit Dr. Westphall on his birthday; Ellen tries to deal with changes to her hometown; Novino stirs up a lady carpenter; Lizzie finally expresses her resentment; and Dr. Craig almost destroys his friendship with Dr. Westphall.

Writer: S.J. Lewis
star
7.29
7 votes

#18 - A Coupla White Dummies Sitting Around Talking

Season 6 - Episode 11 - Aired 12/16/1987

A man claiming to be the true inventor of the Craig 9000 kidnaps Ehrlich; AIDS patient Brett Johnston's rib injuries have led to pneumonia and he is now determined to break with his lover; Dr. Kiem helps Amy Jeffries, a lonely St. Eligius neighbor; Griffin treats a driven young broker determined to make a million before he dies; Lucy worries that she might be pregnant; Helen returns to work; the company that owns the hospital finds itself sued for infringement and Mrs. Spooner ends her husband's suffering.

star
7.29
7 votes

#19 - After Life

Season 5 - Episode 9 - Aired 11/26/1986

Dr. Fiscus is shot. Afterwards, he experiences the afterlife and meets some old friends. Such people include old patients who died in the hospital, a few in limbo and a couple in heaven. However, he is condemed to hades and finds Dr. White swiming in circles for all eternity in a boat with only one oar. Meamwhile, the docs at St. Eligus try their hardest to keep Fiscus alive.

star
7.29
7 votes

#20 - You Beta Your Life

Season 5 - Episode 5 - Aired 10/29/1986

Dr. Westphall helps a terminally ill teenager reach his parents; Griffin plays Birch and Novino off against each other to escape blame in a patient's death; Morrison calls Chandler on it when Dr. Turner gets involved in a dispute involving a sick child; and Dr. Craig tries to start his memoirs.

Directors: Mark Tinker
star
7.33
6 votes

#21 - The Naked Civil Surgeon

Season 6 - Episode 18 - Aired 4/27/1988

Wade and Kiley liberate their psyches during a study of OR infection vectors; Dr. Auschlander meets the son he never knew; Morrison and Novino grow closer as they work in the ICU; and Rosenthal adjusts to life in the chemical dependency unit.

star
7.33
6 votes

#22 - Fairytale Theater

Season 6 - Episode 15 - Aired 2/10/1988

Phil returns from a training course at the Weigert home office; someone takes a shot at Dr. Gideon; Dr. Craig loses Flash during a rescue attempt by animal activists; the new security cameras upset Rosenthal, who continues to lose control; Novino tries to correct a misdiagnosis made 60 years ago, and a show is performed in the children's ward.

star
7.33
6 votes

#23 - Slip Sliding Away

Season 5 - Episode 22 - Aired 5/20/1987

Luther turns sleuth to find out who is responsible for the mercy-killings; Dr. Turner takes a chance doing experimental fetal heart surgery; Axelrod gets back at Novino and Griffin; Morrison buys a gun to protect his family; Yvonne Galecki Craig comes to claim her daughter, and Ehrlich and Papandrao have second thoughts about marriage when the new owners fire everyone in the hospital.

Directors: John Heath
star
7.33
6 votes

#24 - Schwarzwald

Season 5 - Episode 17 - Aired 2/11/1987

Rosenthal tries to help her obese daughter cope with her problems; Axelrod's father brings a dog to the hospital for chemotherapy; Dr. Turner reluctantly reveals the ultrasound results to a couple looking for the perfect baby; and Dr. Westphall continues to try and find a way to keep the hospital open.

star
7.33
6 votes

#25 - When You Wish Upon a Scar

Season 5 - Episode 2 - Aired 10/1/1986

Wade tries to get a grip on her marital problems; Fiscus throws an engagement party for Morrison; Rosenthal figures out the self-serving Griffin; and John Doe #6 returns.

Writer: John Tinker