The WORST episodes of Judy Justice
Every episode of Judy Justice ever, ranked from worst to best by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The worst episodes of Judy Justice!
The Honorable Judy Sheindlin, retired Judge of the Manhattan family Court, brings her signature blend of sharp wit and wisdom, hilarious candor and unwavering honesty that has made her America’s favorite judge for over 25 years, as she presides over real cases, arbitrates binding decisions and delivers what only she can: “Judy Justice.”
#1 - Cat Scratch Tales and Feline Feud
Season 3 - Episode 84 - Aired 9/5/2024
The Judge rules on two cases in this episode. Up first, a female artist sues her ex-boyfriend after losing a $4K commissioned painting, alleging his rambunctious kitten destroyed it. In the next case, custody of "Dumpling" the cat, hangs in the balance as ex-lovers fight over ownership and a GoFundMe campaign for the pet's surgery.
#2 - Family Woes
Season 2 - Episode 20 - Aired 11/29/2022
After providing a home for her grandchildren while her son was in prison, a woman's relationship with her family falls apart after he and his fiance move in.
#3 - Hunting the Cheating Husband
Season 3 - Episode 114 - Aired 10/17/2024
A woman sues her sister after their chaotic pursuit to catch a cheating husband ends in a car crash and dueling damage claims.
#4 - Mother vs Teen Son and Horse Ranch Rumble
Season 3 - Episode 82 - Aired 9/3/2024
Her Honor presides over two cases in this episode. In the first, a mother takes legal action against her unemployed 19-year-old son over a jointly purchased car and multiple reckless driving tickets. Next, an Idaho ranch manager sues an 18-year-old Mustang trainer over the sale of two horses. She alleges that one of the horses was trampled and injured shortly after arriving at its new home.
#5 - Lingerie Loyalty
Season 3 - Episode 83 - Aired 9/4/2024
A teenage girl accuses her former friend's brother of hurling bricks at her car, leading to significant damage. A misguided attempt to test loyalty with a lingerie photo comes into play.
#6 - Wheels of Discord
Season 3 - Episode 79 - Aired 8/29/2024
A woman sues her ex-boyfriend over a jointly-owned car despite his generous gift of a replacement vehicle. A witness' blatant disrespect for the Judge leads to her swift removal from the courtroom.
#7 - Pet Adoption Fail / Texas Natural Disaster Repair
Season 1 - Episode 95 - Aired 3/17/2022
First, a woman accuses the president of a Maltese rescue organization of lying about the pet she adopted. In the next case, a plumber is accused of price-gouging during a natural disaster in Texas.
#8 - High Security Break-Up
Season 2 - Episode 21 - Aired 11/30/2022
A woman is granted a lifetime restraining order against an ex-boyfriend who sues her for thousands in personal belongings he says she never returned.
#9 - Chihuahua Fright
Season 2 - Episode 43 - Aired 2/1/2023
A chihuahua is mauled by a larger dog; neighbors fight over liability and vet bills.
#10 - Mean Girls and Wedding Planner vs. Newlywed
Season 2 - Episode 85 - Aired 3/31/2023
In this episode, the Judge rules on two cases. Up first, a man with 4 children by 3 different women is at the center of a fight between two of the mothers. He remains silent while they fight over harassment, alleged gun-brandishing and vandalism. In the 2nd case, a bride only offers $50 to her planner who paid thousands to help make sure her California ranch wedding took place during the pandemic.
#11 - Rescue Dog Drama
Season 1 - Episode 107 - Aired 3/31/2022
A Marine Corps veteran fights with her stepmother over custody of an elderly, rescue dog.
#12 - You Jumped On My Car! / Last Will and Testament Strife
Season 1 - Episode 109 - Aired 4/4/2022
In the first case, an army vet accuses a car buyer of jumping on her vehicle in an argument over the title. In the next proceeding, a married couple hire a woman to prepare their wills and end up being sued for 8K in damages.
#13 - Tickets and Titles Between Friends / Star-Studded Keytar Crisis
Season 1 - Episode 118 - Aired 4/13/2022
The Judge presides over two cases in this episode. First, a man is sued by a friend for the alleged balance owed on a car; he is questioned about an 'evading the police' text that the Judge discovers. Next up, a software engineer sues a friend over design costs for an array of lights to enhance a keytar; the engineer is countersued for harassment.
#14 - Rag Doll Dog and Hairy Situation
Season 2 - Episode 27 - Aired 12/8/2022
In this episode, the Judge rules on two cases. Up first, two Pit Bulls jump over a fence and maul a neighbor's small dog; the Judge speaks to the responsibility that comes with owning dangerous dog breeds. In the next case, a woman sues a hairstylist claiming money owed for improperly installing a wig and destroying it.
#15 - Music Video Conflict and Family Overstays Welcome
Season 2 - Episode 44 - Aired 2/2/2023
In this episode, the Judge rules on two cases. First, a singer/songwriter sues the owner of a video production company for the money paid for music videos; the producer accuses him of violating their contract. In the next case, a woman sues her brother and sister-in-law for thousands in back rent and for damage to her property; they counter with claims of harassment and invasion of privacy.
#16 - Rims, Barter, and Betrayal
Season 3 - Episode 38 - Aired 3/11/2024
Car enthusiasts clash over an unpaid debt for prized car rims, a failed barter deal, and allegations of aggravated harassment.
#17 - Labradoodle Litigation
Season 3 - Episode 44 - Aired 3/19/2024
A man refuses to pay the adoption fee for a sick Labradoodle puppy, claiming that vet bills far outweigh the animal's value. He admits to giving the pup away when the seller did not retrieve it and that he already has 22 other dogs.
#18 - Barbershop Battle and Dental Adventure in Colombia
Season 3 - Episode 51 - Aired 3/28/2024
The Judge rules on two cases. First, a barbershop owner accuses her former employee of breaching a non-compete agreement by launching a rival shop nearby, a mere three months after leaving her employment. Next, in search of discounted dental work, a couple flies to Colombia for a cosmetic procedure. They break up and proceed to fight over who should pay for the cost of their improved smiles.
#19 - Missing Cat Revenge and Sisterhood of Travelling Drama
Season 3 - Episode 72 - Aired 8/20/2024
The Judge rules on two cases in this episode. First, a man sues his ex-friend for negligence after two cats entrusted to his care go missing. He denies exacting revenge by maliciously redirecting his ex-friend's professional website to a pornographic site. Next, a vacation turns into a legal battle as friends sue their travelling companion, claiming she abandoned their planned trip to Brazil.
#20 - Hidden Horse Injuries
Season 3 - Episode 75 - Aired 8/23/2024
A businessman accuses a seasoned racehorse trainer of reneging on a deal for a horse while she argues she returned the neglected animal due to undisclosed injuries.
#21 - Voicemails and Vengeance and Death-Defying Motorcycle Chase
Season 3 - Episode 76 - Aired 8/26/2024
The Judge rules on two cases in this episode. In the first, a $190 loan between friends escalates into a $10K lawsuit, marked by alcohol-fueled threats and shocking voicemails. Next, in the wake of a friend's deadly motorcycle accident, a man leads police on his own 100mph helmet-less cycle chase through a quiet Ohio town. The aftermath includes a misdemeanor and a battle over legal fees.
#22 - Mercedes Makeover Meltdown
Season 3 - Episode 106 - Aired 10/7/2024
A Florida woman sues a car wrap installer for a botched installation on her $45K Mercedes Benz, intended to attract rental business. She alleges the wrap began peeling off immediately, while the installer blames her choice of cheap materials.
#23 - Love, Loans, and Laid to Rest and Baby Shower Drama
Season 3 - Episode 39 - Aired 3/12/2024
The Judge rules on two cases in this episode. First, after a brief relationship, a single mom sues her ex for payback of a $5K business loan. He insists they weren’t exclusive and that she knew he spent the money on his mother's funeral. Next, a woman claims the father of her children was violent at her baby shower. She says they were no longer intimate after the incident; he argues otherwise.
#24 - Guns Between Friends
Season 2 - Episode 28 - Aired 12/9/2022
A firearms instructor seeks compensation for a valuable rifle he loaned to an ailing client; the defendant says he sold the weapon after the client passed away to satisfy a debt owed by the deceased.
#25 - Lies and Family Ties
Season 4 - Episode 4 - Aired 1/22/2026
After their breakup, a woman sues her ex for stealing money and personal belongings. He countersues, accusing her of neglecting her younger brother and misusing funds meant for his care.