The WORST episodes of Judy Justice
Every episode of Judy Justice ever, ranked from worst to best by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The worst episodes of Judy Justice!
The Honorable Judy Sheindlin, retired Judge of the Manhattan family Court, brings her signature blend of sharp wit and wisdom, hilarious candor and unwavering honesty that has made her America’s favorite judge for over 25 years, as she presides over real cases, arbitrates binding decisions and delivers what only she can: “Judy Justice.”
#1 - Lost in the VR World and Barking Up the Wrong Tree
Season 4 - Episode 48 - Aired 3/25/2026
The Judge rules on two cases in this episode. Up first, a friendly playdate turns nasty when an unsupervised VR gaming session ends in a broken television. Former friends blame each other for the mishap between their children. In the second case, a dispute over a promised pit-bull puppy escalates when a neighbor accuses the other of filing a false CPS report and retaliation after a car incident
#2 - Barking Up the Wrong Caliber and Promises, Promises
Season 4 - Episode 3 - Aired 1/21/2026
The Judge rules on two cases in this episode. First, a tense encounter between a man's tiny hairless dog and an off-leash German shepherd husky escalates when the man pulls a gun for protection, leading to a $10,000 lawsuit over a false arrest. Next, a woman sues her ex-girlfriend over unpaid personal loans, claiming she was deceived with promises of repayment. The ex countersues for harassment.
#3 - Birthday Bash Turns Brutal
Season 3 - Episode 66 - Aired 8/12/2024
A 31st birthday getaway to Tillamook, Oregon, takes a dark turn when a woman sues former friends for an alleged assault during a drunken argument. What began as a celebration in a vacation rental with tequila and a hot tub, spirals into violence, leaving her beaten unconscious, and requiring ongoing eye care.
#4 - The Prison Connection
Season 3 - Episode 3 - Aired 1/22/2024
A 20-year-old with four young children seeks emotional distress compensation when an acquaintance of her incarcerated husband allegedly embarks on a campaign of harassment and defamation.
#5 - Family Road Rage Drama
Season 3 - Episode 36 - Aired 3/7/2024
A blended family sues their landlords after their lease is terminated, triggering a legal dispute involving allegations of harassment, false restraining orders, and property damage. A road rage incident ensues, with the former tenants claiming they were forced off the road and verbally attacked.
#6 - Dude Where's My Truck? and Broken Bonds
Season 2 - Episode 101 - Aired 4/24/2023
The Judge rules on two cases in this episode. In the first, a young man tries to do the right thing when he pays his great aunt $500 for an old truck she left on his property. She sues him for 5K after he disposes of the vehicle. Up next, a man is arrested when an argument with a friend escalates into a public altercation. ‘False' arrest claims are questioned when an active warrant comes to light.
#7 - Beachside Community Fail
Season 2 - Episode 98 - Aired 4/19/2023
A man is sued for property damage to a $1400 a month pool house with no indoor plumbing. He claims his landlord assaulted him in a fight over unpaid utilities and disrespect.
#8 - Car Keying Caught on Tape
Season 2 - Episode 103 - Aired 4/26/2023
A not-so-neighborly dog walk results in vandalism and police intervention. A woman sues for a false arrest, lawyer fees and damages caused by the trauma of a night in jail.
#9 - Baby Horse Rejection and Bad Bug Paint Job
Season 2 - Episode 97 - Aired 4/18/2023
Her Honor presides over two cases in this episode. In the first case, a woman makes a deposit on a foal six months before its birth but wants out of the contract once the animal is born. Believing the baby horse could not be insured, she sues for breach of contract. In the second case, a disabled veteran sues for a $6500 refund when the paint job on her beloved 1969 Volkswagen starts 'bubbling'.
#10 - Cash Not Cops
Season 2 - Episode 96 - Aired 4/17/2023
To avoid points on his driving record, a trucker offers cash to a fellow motorist after an accident. Their arrangement falls apart when repair estimate amounts and dates vary wildly.
#11 - Grand Theft Child
Season 2 - Episode 90 - Aired 4/7/2023
After 'kidnapping' her own child from a family member and evading police, a woman is charged with child endangerment and spends four months in jail. She accuses her mother of stealing thousands from her while she was imprisoned.
#12 - He Stole My Land!
Season 2 - Episode 94 - Aired 4/13/2023
When neighbors feud over property and attorney fees, the Judge shares her own personal story about a neighbor who refused to amicably resolve an easement issue.
#13 - Bullet-Riddled Betrayal
Season 3 - Episode 16 - Aired 2/8/2024
During an outing to purchase illegal drugs, a teenager driving his girlfriend’s car is caught in gun crossfire. To evade shots fired, he swerves and crashes the vehicle. His girlfriend reports the car as stolen and seeks $7K in damages to her now bullet-ridden ride.
#14 - Cat Scratch Tales and Feline Feud
Season 3 - Episode 84 - Aired 9/5/2024
The Judge rules on two cases in this episode. Up first, a female artist sues her ex-boyfriend after losing a $4K commissioned painting, alleging his rambunctious kitten destroyed it. In the next case, custody of "Dumpling" the cat, hangs in the balance as ex-lovers fight over ownership and a GoFundMe campaign for the pet's surgery.
#15 - Meet the Truth! and Loan Shark Sticker Shock
Season 2 - Episode 104 - Aired 4/27/2023
In this episode, the Judge rules on two cases. Up first, a man changes his story many times when asked to prove that monies loaned to him by an ex were never meant to be paid back. In the next case, following their break-up, a man loans the mother of his child 10K to escape the burden of 500-800% interest rates on her personal debt. They fight over payback when a new boyfriend comes into play.
#16 - Farmin' Pigs Profit Margin
Season 2 - Episode 111 - Aired 5/8/2023
In a small Idaho farming community, a teenager sells four piglets to a neighbor and expects to be paid in full. The buyer claims all four animals died and that he owes nothing.
#17 - Mother and Son Fallout and Crypto Controversy
Season 2 - Episode 102 - Aired 4/25/2023
In this episode, the Judge rules on two cases. Up first, a mother and son are no longer on speaking terms after a deal to purchase a van falls apart. He claims the inoperable van was a gift and that any discussion of money was only to appease her after the fact. In the next case, a mechanical engineer and a programmer fight over profits from their shared cryptocurrency mining business.
#18 - Foster Child's Fire Damage
Season 3 - Episode 22 - Aired 2/16/2024
An ex-foster youth pursuing a career as a social worker sues her ex-boyfriend's parents after a house fire destroyed her belongings. She contends that the defendants exploited her receipts for insurance reimbursement while they claim she already received compensation through gift cards.
#19 - Wage Wars and Golf Cart Goes Rogue
Season 3 - Episode 20 - Aired 2/14/2024
The Judge rules on two cases in this episode. First, the husband and wife owners of a California production design company make the mistake of overpaying an employee by more than $6000. They seek payback for lost wages and emotional distress. In the second case, longtime golfing buddies dispute the 'negligent' moving of a golf cart that rolled down a driveway and slammed into a BMW.
#20 - Hit-and-Run House Slam and 'Kayak Conflict
Season 2 - Episode 106 - Aired 5/1/2023
Her Honor presides over two cases in this episode. In the first case, a victim of a hit-and-run makes the split-second decision to slam her car into a house instead of oncoming traffic. Her actions may have saved lives, but she is sued for property damage by a homeowner. Up next, an alcohol-fueled altercation over a cheating girlfriend leaves friends at odds over an alleged assault and two kayaks.
#21 - Family Woes
Season 2 - Episode 20 - Aired 11/29/2022
After providing a home for her grandchildren while her son was in prison, a woman's relationship with her family falls apart after he and his fiance move in.
#22 - Hunting the Cheating Husband
Season 3 - Episode 114 - Aired 10/17/2024
A woman sues her sister after their chaotic pursuit to catch a cheating husband ends in a car crash and dueling damage claims.
#23 - Money, Mischief, and a One-Eyed Cat and The Harley and the Frenchie
Season 3 - Episode 18 - Aired 2/12/2024
The Judge rules on two cases in this episode. First, a man accuses his ex-girlfriend of embezzling several thousand dollars. She claims he intentionally injured her cat, causing the beloved pet to lose an eye. Next, motorcycle enthusiasts accuse a man of stealing their antique Harley-Davidson and sue for $10K. The man claims he paid for the cycle in 'shatter' (a marijuana concentrate).
#24 - Child Support Showdown and Dog Attack Drama
Season 3 - Episode 23 - Aired 2/19/2024
The Judge rules on two cases in this episode. First, a mother demands payback from her ex-husband for their older son's medical bills and car repairs, claiming he agreed to cover these expenses. He refuses ongoing support for their adult child who lives at home and is employed. Next, a student seeks $10K for pain and suffering, as she dramatically alleges being bitten by her roommate's dog.
#25 - Mother vs Teen Son and Horse Ranch Rumble
Season 3 - Episode 82 - Aired 9/3/2024
Her Honor presides over two cases in this episode. In the first, a mother takes legal action against her unemployed 19-year-old son over a jointly purchased car and multiple reckless driving tickets. Next, an Idaho ranch manager sues an 18-year-old Mustang trainer over the sale of two horses. She alleges that one of the horses was trampled and injured shortly after arriving at its new home.