The BEST episodes of On the Case with Paula Zahn season 16

Every episode of On the Case with Paula Zahn season 16, ranked from best to worst by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The best episodes of On the Case with Paula Zahn season 16!

Led by Emmy Award-winning journalist Paula Zahn, ON THE CASE features in-depth interviews and original reporting that go beyond the headlines in search of fascinating mysteries from within our nation's justice system. Each episode is highlighted by Zahn's riveting exclusive interviews, which draw out different viewpoints from the people personally connected to tragedies that rocked their local community and the investigations that attempted to piece together the truth.

Last Updated: 12/3/2024Network: Investigation DiscoveryStatus: Continuing
Stolen Dreams
star
7.72
18 votes

#1 - Stolen Dreams

Season 16 - Episode 2 - Aired 11/5/2017

John Greathouse finds his stepdaughter, Kelli Bailey, murdered in her bedroom; investigators find a video tape and a dead man's forged check and hope these clues will be the keys to bringing Bailey's cold-blooded killer to justice.

Watch Now:Apple TV
A Nightmare in Idaho Falls
star
7.59
22 votes

#2 - A Nightmare in Idaho Falls

Season 16 - Episode 1 - Aired 10/31/2017

Reeda Roundy and Betty Gray are found murdered in Roundy's home, along with a message written in blood, saying ``Satan Loves You;'' detectives piece together the stunning truth behind the murders with insights provided by the victims' families.

Watch Now:Apple TV
In the Shadows of Home
star
7.52
27 votes

#3 - In the Shadows of Home

Season 16 - Episode 10 - Aired 2/18/2018

The body of a teenager is found savagely murdered just steps from her home; when the investigation stalls, police are approached by a brave young woman who is willing to risk her own safety to get justice.

Watch Now:Apple TV
Scattered Clues, Shattered Lives
star
7.47
19 votes

#4 - Scattered Clues, Shattered Lives

Season 16 - Episode 11 - Aired 2/25/2018

A wave of fear sweeps across Aurora, Colo., after two similar crimes are committed just days apart, and police race to stop a hammer-wielding killer before he strikes again.

Watch Now:Apple TV
River of Sorrow
star
7.26
19 votes

#5 - River of Sorrow

Season 16 - Episode 13 - Aired 3/11/2018

A young woman is savagely murdered while fishing along the Platte River.

Watch Now:Apple TV
As She Lay Dying
star
7.25
20 votes

#6 - As She Lay Dying

Season 16 - Episode 12 - Aired 3/4/2018

A young mother is viciously stabbed in broad daylight, and her final words may provide police with the key to catching her killer.

Watch Now:Apple TV
A Lifetime of Questions
star
7.25
20 votes

#7 - A Lifetime of Questions

Season 16 - Episode 14 - Aired 3/18/2018

As a 4-year-old girl, Heidi Jones discovered her mother's lifeless body on the living room floor; now, as an adult, Jones guides police on a relentless quest to find her mother's killer.

Watch Now:Apple TV
A Predator in Deerfield
star
7.18
28 votes

#8 - A Predator in Deerfield

Season 16 - Episode 8 - Aired 1/28/2018

When a young woman and her 6-month-old child disappear off the quiet streets of Deerfield Beach, Fla., it is the beginning of a terrifying murder mystery.

Watch Now:Apple TV
Stacy's Story
star
7.11
18 votes

#9 - Stacy's Story

Season 16 - Episode 6 - Aired 1/7/2018

A mother finds her teenage daughter murdered in their own home; decades later, a few drops of blood are discovered and may hold the key to solving the cold case.

Watch Now:Apple TV
A Murder in Coralville
star
7.09
22 votes

#10 - A Murder in Coralville

Season 16 - Episode 7 - Aired 1/21/2018

A young woman is found shot to death near a dirt road; police hope the bullet found at the scene will unmask her killer.

Watch Now:Apple TV
Twisted Lies
star
7.05
20 votes

#11 - Twisted Lies

Season 16 - Episode 3 - Aired 11/12/2017

In Las Vegas, 41-year-old Nancy Menke, a mother of four, is found handcuffed and murdered in the passenger seat of her car; a records clerk in the insurance fraud unit stumbles upon a strange report that blows open Menke's murder case.

Watch Now:Apple TV
In the Blink of an Eye
star
7.00
19 votes

#12 - In the Blink of an Eye

Season 16 - Episode 9 - Aired 2/11/2018

A convenience store worker is abducted from behind the counter in the middle of the night, becoming the first of three women to disappear from their small town under shockingly similar circumstances.

Watch Now:Apple TV
A Daughter's Quest
star
6.92
25 votes

#13 - A Daughter's Quest

Season 16 - Episode 16 - Aired 4/1/2018

A young woman's search for her birth mother leads to a quest for justice.

Watch Now:Apple TV
Last Night Before Murder
star
6.81
21 votes

#14 - Last Night Before Murder

Season 16 - Episode 15 - Aired 3/25/2018

A young mother inexplicably disappears in the middle of the night only to be found savagely murdered the next morning, prompting police to retrace the tumultuous events of her last night on Earth.

Watch Now:Apple TV
That's Him!
star
6.64
14 votes

#15 - That's Him!

Season 16 - Episode 5 - Aired 11/26/2017

A successful car salesman is killed in a hail of gunfire that erupts on his front porch.

Watch Now:Apple TV
Deadly Hymn
star
6.58
12 votes

#16 - Deadly Hymn

Season 16 - Episode 4 - Aired 11/19/2017

The murder of a beloved and talented church organist sends police on a disturbing search for answers.

Watch Now:Apple TV