The BEST episodes of An Unexpected Killer

Every episode of An Unexpected Killer ever, ranked from best to worst by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The best episodes of An Unexpected Killer!

A look at homicide investigations that conclude with the killer's true identity coming as a shocking surprise.

Last Updated: 1/28/2023Network:Oxygen
Share:
Death on the Driveway
star
7.83
6 votes

#1 - Death on the Driveway

Season 3 - Episode 14 - Aired 10/7/2022

When a loving father of two is gunned down on his driveway, police uncover a hidden affair and workplace grudges before a nervous witness and chilling confession reveal a vicious vendetta from a killer no one expected.

Watch Now:Amazon
Twisted Attraction
star
7.76
21 votes

#2 - Twisted Attraction

Season 2 - Episode 15 - Aired 5/7/2021

When a young woman who was just starting out in life is found assaulted and stabbed to death in her boyfriend’s home, detectives work tirelessly to uncover a killer who had previously been above suspicion, leaving the town and police force stunned.

Watch Now:Amazon
Dying to See You
star
7.74
54 votes

#3 - Dying to See You

Season 1 - Episode 2 - Aired 12/12/2019

When a popular college student is found slain in the middle of campus, police suspect his friends and lovers might be involved.

Watch Now:AmazoniTunes
When Hate Kills
star
7.72
43 votes

#4 - When Hate Kills

Season 1 - Episode 4 - Aired 12/26/2019

Police in small town Louisiana investigate the mysterious and brutal murder of a beloved neighbor with no known enemies.

Watch Now:AmazoniTunes
The Love That Kills
star
7.71
21 votes

#5 - The Love That Kills

Season 2 - Episode 5 - Aired 2/12/2021

A loving, single mother of two is the victim of a bizarre murder, leading detectives to investigate a number of suspects, until a killer with a dark obsession hiding in plain sight is revealed.

Watch Now:Amazon
A Silent Death
star
7.70
10 votes

#6 - A Silent Death

Season 3 - Episode 13 - Aired 9/30/2022

A beloved teacher and mother of four silently vanishes in the middle of the night. A blood-soaked bedroom and horrific lakeside discovery point police to a killer close to home until mysterious tracks in the mud lead to a culprit no one suspected

Watch Now:Amazon
Gold-Blooded Murder
star
7.67
18 votes

#7 - Gold-Blooded Murder

Season 3 - Episode 2 - Aired 3/11/2022

A fun-loving 59-year-old man is found shot to death in his home and his beloved jewelry collection stolen, leading detectives to a long list of suspects and a killer harboring a dark secret.

Watch Now:Amazon
The Ties That Bind
star
7.67
9 votes

#8 - The Ties That Bind

Season 3 - Episode 9 - Aired 4/29/2022

A wealthy trader and father of four is gunned-down at home while his family is tied up in a closet. Police dig into affairs, mob links and a missing coworker, until a chilling new lead and a taped phone call reveal a shocking plot decades later.

Watch Now:Amazon
Wicked Night Out
star
7.67
12 votes

#9 - Wicked Night Out

Season 3 - Episode 10 - Aired 5/6/2022

When a young mother is found dead in a field after a night out, police scour security video to retrace a suspect's steps. The discovery of a second crime scene leads to an arrest, before hi-tech forensics reveal a truth no one expected.

Watch Now:Amazon
A Date With Death
star
7.67
12 votes

#10 - A Date With Death

Season 3 - Episode 11 - Aired 9/16/2022

A cat-loving and recently divorced young woman dipping her toes back in the dating game is beaten and strangled in a brutal and unusual way; investigators dive into the murky world of online dating to hunt a killer who could be ready to strike again.

Watch Now:Amazon
Killed by Kindness
star
7.63
19 votes

#11 - Killed by Kindness

Season 2 - Episode 6 - Aired 2/19/2021

When a recently divorced mother is found strangled to death on her couch, several suspects emerge until the killer is revealed to be someone close to home.

Watch Now:Amazon
Blood Runs Thick
star
7.63
8 votes

#12 - Blood Runs Thick

Season 3 - Episode 17 - Aired 10/28/2022

Could the execution-style shooting of a well-loved, self-made couple be a tragic case of mistaken identity? Early leads take police down a path of greed and desperation until a paper trail leads to a calculated betrayal shockingly close to home.

Watch Now:Amazon
Deadly Disrespect
star
7.60
25 votes

#13 - Deadly Disrespect

Season 2 - Episode 9 - Aired 3/12/2021

After a 35-year-old analyst for the NSA is fatally stabbed, police look at a number of suspects; detectives close in on the killer, but the investigation takes a shocking turn.

Watch Now:Amazon
Fatal Ambition
star
7.59
22 votes

#14 - Fatal Ambition

Season 2 - Episode 8 - Aired 3/5/2021

A hard-working young woman is discovered stabbed at the side of a road, leading police on a tireless investigation for 10 years to unveil a killer who is hiding in plain sight.

Watch Now:Amazon
A Love Lost
star
7.59
17 votes

#15 - A Love Lost

Season 3 - Episode 4 - Aired 3/25/2022

When a young husband-to-be is found shot and stabbed, detectives investigate a secret affair, a kidnapping plot and a terrifying racist gang before unveiling a killer whose hidden criminal life leaves everyone stunned.

Watch Now:Amazon
A Genius Murder
star
7.59
29 votes

#16 - A Genius Murder

Season 2 - Episode 3 - Aired 1/29/2021

When a brilliant scientist and devoted family man is found beaten to death, the evidence leads police to make arrests, but an astounding revelation turns the investigation on its head.

Watch Now:Amazon
Twisted Intentions
star
7.58
12 votes

#17 - Twisted Intentions

Season 3 - Episode 12 - Aired 9/23/2022

Detectives discover the badly beaten body of a single young woman left bizarrely staged on her bed; fear in the community grows amid a rash of nearby murders until police are handed a break when a fresh look at old evidence points to the killer.

Watch Now:Amazon
The Mayor's Wife
star
7.57
21 votes

#18 - The Mayor's Wife

Season 2 - Episode 12 - Aired 4/2/2021

After a respected educator and mother of two is found dead in small-town Alabama, the investigation focuses on fraught family relationships, but the discovery of a dark secret unveils a killer no one saw coming.

Watch Now:Amazon
Fatal Fast Food
star
7.57
14 votes

#19 - Fatal Fast Food

Season 3 - Episode 3 - Aired 3/18/2022

A restaurant is robbed and the night manager murdered leading police to investigate suspicious coworkers, a disgruntled ex-employee and a violent serial attacker. The case goes cold, but explosive new evidence leads to a killer nobody suspected.

Watch Now:Amazon
Shot In The Dark
star
7.57
14 votes

#20 - Shot In The Dark

Season 3 - Episode 7 - Aired 4/15/2022

A brutal assassination, bitter custody dispute and a gunman's cryptic words send police scrambling on an interstate hunt to find the killer of a beloved father and husband, revealing a hair-raising plot more sinister than anyone suspected.

Watch Now:Amazon
Hidden Betrayal
star
7.56
18 votes

#21 - Hidden Betrayal

Season 2 - Episode 13 - Aired 4/9/2021

A civic-minded teen is shot to death in his own bed, but just as investigators are closing in on those responsible, a twist leaves everyone stunned.

Watch Now:Amazon
Killer in Plain Sight
star
7.55
42 votes

#22 - Killer in Plain Sight

Season 1 - Episode 5 - Aired 1/2/2020

After a college student is viciously murdered and her apartment set ablaze, police untangle a web of relationships to find a killer who's dangerously close to home

Watch Now:AmazoniTunes
Second Chance to Kill
star
7.53
19 votes

#23 - Second Chance to Kill

Season 2 - Episode 16 - Aired 5/14/2021

Police hunting the killer of a beloved grandfather believe his missing truck holds the key to the case. After hunting down suspect after suspect, local PD found a killer close to home, wielding a shocking kill weapon in a story of sickening betrayal.

Watch Now:Amazon
Unseen Assassin
star
7.52
33 votes

#24 - Unseen Assassin

Season 2 - Episode 2 - Aired 1/22/2021

A wealthy businessman and his closest friend are found shot execution-style; police have little to go on until a surprising development leads investigators to a killer no one ever suspected.

Watch Now:Amazon
A Ringing Suspicion
star
7.50
14 votes

#25 - A Ringing Suspicion

Season 3 - Episode 8 - Aired 4/22/2022

When the strangling death of a young mother and bride-to-be baffles police, detectives probe a workplace grievance in search of a killer, before a cherished possession provides a link to the crime and cracks the case wide open.

Watch Now:Amazon

Want to see the rest of the rankings?

Episode Ninja is a small business run by one person.
Pro memberships help fund servers and new feature development!