The WORST episodes of Fatal Attraction
Every episode of Fatal Attraction ever, ranked from worst to best by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The worst episodes of Fatal Attraction!
Each pulse-pounding hour-long episode of Fatal Attraction centers around an incredible and dangerous romance. Shocking crime, kidnapping or even murder is only half of the story! In the end, the “true love” that draws these couples together isn’t the kind that celebrates silver anniversaries – instead it leads to cross-country manhunts, bizarre cover-ups and dramatic trials. Driven by powerful, real-life stories, Fatal Attraction weaves together intimate, first-person interviews, exclusive interrogation footage and rare archival material. Along the way, it gives you a glimpse into the dark heart of a dangerous romance. Listen as the key players, family of the survivors and those that investigated the horrific crimes reveal the secrets to each sordid tale. Fatal Attraction…because love doesn’t just hurt. It can kill!
#1 - Murder in Niagara
Season 2 - Episode 5 - Aired 1/13/2014
On the surface, Robert and Ahkenya Johnson had a picture perfect marriage. But according to friends and family, Robert’s behavior had become increasingly erratic. When the mother of two is found by her husband was he the last person to see her alive? He’s got an alibi, but will it convince authorities and Ahkenya’s family?
Watch Now:iTunes#2 - Tragic Rebound
Season 2 - Episode 6 - Aired 1/27/2014
Tamika Huston had big dreams of becoming a singer and a promising future ahead of her, but when she inexplicably goes missing, friends and family worry they’ll never get to see her reach her full potential. The search for answers will lead law enforcement down a slew of different paths—will they ever be able to track down this beautiful young songstress?
Watch Now:iTunes#3 - Hell Hath No Fury
Season 2 - Episode 7 - Aired 2/3/2014
Brian and Elicia Hughes seemed to have a picture perfect marriage; high school sweethearts with two daughters and a nice home in an affluent neighborhood. But when a 911 call leads to a disturbing crime, their perfect life turns up to be not so perfect.
#4 - Sins & Secrets
Season 2 - Episode 8 - Aired 2/10/2014
Pastor Anthony Hopkins and his wife, Arletha, were living their dreams with their seven beautiful children. Years later, someone comes forward with a shocking revelation that will prove there was more to Arletha’s death than anyone could ever imagine.
Watch Now:Amazon#5 - Budding Bloodsheed
Season 2 - Episode 9 - Aired 2/24/2014
Tiffany and Antwan fell head over heels in love for each other, but once Tiffany had Antwan’s child, she found starting a family in high school was far from easy. And when an argument between the two lovers leaves Antwan dead, everyone’s wondering what could push this girl to kill her first love.
#6 - Raging Revenge
Season 2 - Episode 10 - Aired 3/3/2014
Tawanna Barnes-Copeland seemed to have it all – three beautiful daughters and a budding romance. Until one fateful day when her daughter came home to find the unthinkable. The investigation would leave detectives wondering – was Tawanna the victim of a deadly robbery? Or was there someone out there who wanted her dead?
#7 - Horror on the Highway
Season 2 - Episode 11 - Aired 3/10/2014
The story of Ryan and Serika Holness begins in Jamaica, but ends tragically in a Maryland field. Ryan’s reports of a carjacker sends police on a manhunt but when detectives add up the evidence, they start to believe the killer may be closer than they think.
#8 - If I Can’t Have You
Season 2 - Episode 12 - Aired 3/17/2014
When dashing young Michael Brooks falls for a sexy older woman named Dorothy Washington, their desire for each other can’t be contained. But when Michael is brutally gunned down inside Dorothy’s apartment, their steamy romance would be forever put on hold. As law enforcement attempt to piece together what happened, they uncover a twisted tale of lies, jealousy, and violence.
#9 - Fallen Hero
Season 2 - Episode 13 - Aired 3/24/2014
When Officer Wayne Irby stops by Denise Miller’s home on a courtesy call, she falls hard for the man in uniform. But when both Wayne and Denise turn up missing, his fellow officers find out just how mad love can be!
#10 - Texas Tragedy
Season 2 - Episode 14 - Aired 3/31/2014
When beautiful young coed Tynesha Stewart goes missing just miles from her boyfriend’s apartment, her family and friends grow more anxious by the hour. But a shocking confession from a familiar face not only divulges Tynesha’s fate, but also the presence of a true monster, and a sickening crime.
#11 - A Lethal Love Affair
Season 2 - Episode 15 - Aired 6/9/2014
Young newlyweds Latrese and Darin Curtis were reveling in the joy of their fledgling marriage—but no sooner had they begun their new life together than Latrese would be murdered in a horrific act of violence. Found stabbed to death on the side of a busy highway, investigators are puzzled as to who would want to harm such a beloved young woman in such a brutal fashion. The search for answers will uncover a tangled web of sex, lies, and salacious secrets that will shock even the most seasoned investigators.
#12 - Burning Rage
Season 2 - Episode 16 - Aired 6/16/2014
Latonya Bowman and Jamal Rogers were one month shy of welcoming their baby boy into the world when the unthinkable happened. Latonya is kidnapped, set on fire, shot, and left for dead. As Latonya fights to save her life and the life of her unborn son, detectives try to figure out who would want to harm her – and in such a violent way. As this mystery begins to unravel they uncover a selfish murder plot that sends shockwaves throughout the Detroit community – and the entire country.
#13 - All in the Family
Season 2 - Episode 17 - Aired 6/23/2014
When mother of three Kenyatae Collier-Brewer goes missing, her husband Darron immediately notifies police. The search is on for this beloved nurse before time runs out. But after investigators uncover her abandoned vehicle, they are quickly thrust into a twisted tale of deception and betrayal.
#14 - Harvard Homicide
Season 2 - Episode 18 - Aired 6/30/2014
Brittany Smith and Jabrai Copney were a young collegiate power-couple who had the world at their fingertips. But their textbook romance is cut short when a young man is murdered in broad daylight on Harvard’s campus – where Brittany is a proud student. When Brittany inexplicably goes missing soon after this tragedy occurs, investigators wonder if there might have been two victims. When they dig deeper, they’ll uncover a tangled web of lies that will shock the entire Cambridge community.
#15 - Deadly Rampage
Season 2 - Episode 19 - Aired 7/7/2014
A modern day Bonnie and Clyde, Shanda Merritt and Carl Davis had penchant for criminal behavior. But when Carl decides to leave Shanda and go on the straight and narrow, it sparks a chain reaction of heinous acts leaving one man dead and another in critical condition.
#16 - Love Triangle Tragedy
Season 2 - Episode 20 - Aired 7/14/2014
When 22-year-old airport baggage handler Erika Yancey goes missing, friends and family scramble with law enforcement to find her. Erika had a habit of meeting strangers online, which leads her family to fear that she may have gotten caught up with the wrong person. But once the search gets going, a steamy affair and a tangled love triangle will be revealed that will send the case spiraling in a whole new direction. The question isn’t only if they’ll find Erika…it’s if they’ll find her alive.
#17 - Pure Evil
Season 2 - Episode 21 - Aired 7/21/2014
Eddy Curry and Nova Henry have a relationship that turns rocky once Eddy is drafted to the NBA and she has two of his children. But when Nova and her 10-month old daughter Ava turn up dead in the wake of a child support case, police are baffled as to what monster could commit such a heinous crime.
#18 - Millionaire Murder
Season 2 - Episode 22 - Aired 7/28/2014
Lance Herndon was renown throughout Atlanta for being one of the city’s most successful businessmen and dashing playboys. Celebrated for his rigorous work ethic and lavish parties, Lance was viewed as Atlanta’s own “Great Gatsby.” But when his mother finds him bludgeoned to death one morning in his bedroom, no one can fathom what Lance could have done to deserve such a graphic beating. After a slew of greedy mistresses are unveiled, they become investigators’ prime suspects—but could any of these petite women really be capable of such a violent crime?
Watch Now:Amazon#19 - A Sinister Affair
Season 3 - Episode 3 - Aired 1/19/2015
Yamisha Thomas and Sylvester Davis had chemistry that couldn’t be tamed; sparks flew in the bedroom, and Sylvester was a great father figure for Yamisha’s young daughter. Just when it seemed their relationship couldn’t get more perfect, Yamisha goes inexplicably missing after she fails to pick up her daughter from a family member’s home. Detectives are puzzled as to what could’ve happened to this beautiful young mother. The investigation into her disappearance will reveal some alarming secrets, and beg the question…did her past come back to haunt her?
Watch Now:AmazoniTunes#20 - Deadly Secret
Season 3 - Episode 4 - Aired 1/26/2015
“Cece” Dove was a vivacious young woman looking for love. But when she mysteriously disappears, investigators can’t help but wonder if her online dating profile could have landed her in the hands of an internet predator. On the other side of town the body of a male is discovered, the victim of a heinous murder. Investigators make an incredible discovery causing the cases to collide in the most shocking of ways.
Watch Now:AmazoniTunes#21 - Dance of Death
Season 3 - Episode 5 - Aired 2/2/2015
Debbie Flores-Narvaez was a beautiful showgirl looking to fall in love. When she vanishes without a trace, investigators can’t help but wonder if she had gotten caught up in the lifestyle of the night and ended up as just another of the lost souls missing from the City of Sin. But when Debbie’s car turns up across town, investigators uncover a love triangle involving the reigning queen of the Vegas showgirls and a dark secret so lurid it could be worth killing for.
Watch Now:iTunes#22 - Deadly Jealousy
Season 3 - Episode 6 - Aired 2/9/2015
Jennifer Lewis never expected that she’d have a relationship as meaningful as the one she had with God, but that changed when she met the charming and devout Melvin Reed. Soon, a fast and deep romance blossomed, held together by their mutual love of God. Jennifer and Melvin’s romance is snuffed out prematurely when she is shot on campus at close-range. Is it possible a secret from her past has come back to haunt her or had her search for love put her in contact with something much more sinister?
Watch Now:iTunes#23 - The Boy Is Mine
Season 3 - Episode 7 - Aired 2/23/2015
Curtisha Morning was an ambitious young student focused on her career and not her love life, but that all changed when she met Carl Brown. He opened up a new exciting world that Curtisha had never experienced. When Curtisha vanishes into thin air, investigators are at a loss as to what could have happened to the ambitious young teen. Soon, a dark secret is exposed, one so reprehensible it just might prove motive for murder.
Watch Now:Amazon#24 - Mortal Matrimony
Season 3 - Episode 8 - Aired 3/2/2015
For Juatasha Denton, failure was not in her vocabulary. She always got what she wanted in life and love, and what she wanted most was Ray McCaster. Soon, innocent flirtations turned into full-blown romance and they ended up tying the knot. Their happy world of married bliss is shattered when a dismembered body is found just miles from the couple’s house. Investigators uncover a secret so dark it may just have brought the young lovers onto a collision course with evil.
#25 - AWOL Abduction
Season 3 - Episode 9 - Aired 3/9/2015
When Kimberly Parker said “I do” to, Elihue Parker, he promised her the world, but their dreams for a bright future are dashed when Elihue turns up missing. As investigators delve deeper, they uncover a twisted ring of greed and deception that will leave them face to face with pure evil.
Want to see the rest of the rankings?
Episode Ninja is a small business run by one person.
Pro memberships help fund servers and new feature development!