The BEST Episodes of Eerie, Indiana

Every episode ever - ranked by fan votes!

Last Updated: Sep 4, 2019

Network: NBC

Eerie, Indiana, a place where nothing is quite what it seems. The series, revolves around 13 year-old Marshall Teller and his friend Simon encountering all the weirdness Eerie has to offer. From Tupperware that will keep anything fresh to braces that translate what dogs say into English, Eerie is the "center of weirdness" for the entire world.

Reality Takes a Holiday

#1 - Reality Takes a Holiday

Season 1 - Episode 18

Marshall finds a script in the mailbox and starts reading. Suddenly he finds himself on the set of a TV series where everybody refers to him as Omri.

star 8.08
13 votes
Directors: Ken Kwapis
Writers: Vance DeGeneres
The Lost Hour

#2 - The Lost Hour

Season 1 - Episode 10

Marshal doesn't like the Indiana practice of ignoring daylight savings time, and sets his clock back an hour anyway. When he wakes up the next day, nobody's around... except some very untalkative garbage men, intent on sending him though the trash compactor.

star 8.04
24 votes
Directors: Bob Balaban
Writers: Vance DeGeneres
The Loyal Order of Corn

#3 - The Loyal Order of Corn

Season 1 - Episode 16

Strange things are going on in Eerie's local lodge - The Loyal Order of Corn, and when his father joins Marshall intends to find out what.

star 7.79
14 votes
Directors: Bryan Spicer
Writers: Michael Cassutt
Foreverware

#4 - Foreverware

Season 1 - Episode 1

The Tellers are welcomed to Eerie by Betty Wilson, who invites Marilyn to attend a demonstration of Foreverware, a very special type of plastic container: It's guaranteed keep anything fresh... Forever.

star 7.68
71 votes
Directors: Joe Dante
Writers: Karl Schaefer, Jose Rivera
The Broken Record

#5 - The Broken Record

Season 1 - Episode 19

Marshall tries to get a gloomy friend to lighten up by showing him an album from the heavy metal band Pitbull Surfers, but soon the Eerie weirdness kicks in and the quiet overachiever is turned into rebellious headbanger.

star 7.65
17 votes
Directors: Tom Holland
Writers: Jose Rivera
Tornado Days

#6 - Tornado Days

Season 1 - Episode 12

As the tornado ""Old Bob"" approaches Eerie, the citizens prepare for their annual tornado day picnic to appease him. But Marshall and Simon insist on staying home, and as the tornado chasing meteorologist left by Bob on his first pass-though tells them - and this makes Bob angry.

star 7.62
21 votes
Directors: Ken Kwapis
Writers: Michael Cassutt
Who's Who

#7 - Who's Who

Season 1 - Episode 9

A troubled young girl with a penchant for drawing can suddenly change reality when she starts signing her pictures with an Eerie brand pencil.

star 7.61
18 votes
Directors: Tim Hunter
Writers: Julia Poll
Just Say No Fun

#8 - Just Say No Fun

Season 1 - Episode 6

Marshall knows something's up when he's sent to the new school nurse instead of detention, and his suspicions are confirmed when Simon comes out from the sight check as a homework-loving zombie.

star 7.61
33 votes
Directors: Bryan Spicer
Writers: Michael R. Perry
America's Scariest Home Video

#9 - America's Scariest Home Video

Season 1 - Episode 5

Stuck having to baby-sit Simon's younger brother on Halloween, Marshall and Simon fool around with their video camera. Unfortunately they end up trapping him in a monster movie, while a mummy runs wild in their house.

star 7.59
29 votes
Directors: Sam Pillsbury
Writers: Karl Schaefer
Heart on a Chain

#10 - Heart on a Chain

Season 1 - Episode 7

Marshall and a classmate both fall for a new girl. The boy gives her a locket shaped like a heart. When the boy is in a terrible accident, his heart is transplanted into her body. Marshall suspects that something is wrong when the girl starts acting like his dead friend.

star 7.57
28 votes
Directors: Joe Dante
Writers: Jose Rivera
The Dead Letter

#11 - The Dead Letter

Season 1 - Episode 8

While browsing the basement of the local library, Marshall finds an old letter. He opens it and a young man appears who won't leave him alone until he delivers the letter in person.

star 7.52
23 votes
Directors: Tim Hunter
Writers: James L. Crite
Zombies in P.J.s

#12 - Zombies in P.J.s

Season 1 - Episode 17

Facing bankruptcy due to a possible audit, Radford welcomes a new partner - The Donald. His aggressive ad camping has customers sleepwalking to the World 'o Stuff's midnight madness sale, buying anything in sight on credit. Just sign on the dotted line...

star 7.50
14 votes
Directors: Bob Balaban
Writers: Julia Poll
The Retainer

#13 - The Retainer

Season 1 - Episode 2

Marshall is scheduled to visit the dentist for a retainer. But he fears that he might end up the same way as the previous retainer recipient - He became able to hear what the dogs really say, and that was something they really didn't like.

star 7.46
52 votes
Directors: Joe Dante
Writers: Karl Schaefer, Jose Rivera
The ATM with the Heart of Gold

#14 - The ATM with the Heart of Gold

Season 1 - Episode 3

Simon befriends Eerie's new intelligent ATM, who gives him all the money he wants. Meanwhile, citizens of Eerie notice their bank accounts drying out.

star 7.46
46 votes
Directors: Sam Pillsbury
Writers: Matt Dearborn
The Losers

#15 - The Losers

Season 1 - Episode 4

Mr. Teller is losing things left and right. When he loses his briefcase, an anniversary gift from his wife also containing important things, Mrs. Teller becomes upset. Marshall sets out to find where the missing items are going and with help from Simon, they make a startling discovery.

star 7.41
32 votes
Writers: Gary Markowitz
Marshall's Theory of Believability

#16 - Marshall's Theory of Believability

Season 1 - Episode 11

A professor renowned as an authority on the supernatural comes to Eerie to observe an extraterrestrial object he believes will land here. Marshall immediately sees an opportunity to blow the lid of the Eerie weirdness; but is the professor really all that he claims to be.

star 7.37
16 votes
Directors: Bob Balaban
Writers: Matt Dearborn
No Brain, No Pain

#17 - No Brain, No Pain

Season 1 - Episode 15

A strange bum is assaulted by a woman with a ray gun. distracts her until the police arrive, and then Marshall decides to help out a bum after witnessing him being attacked by a woman with a ray gun. It is difficult though, because all he does is mumble nonsense, and reassemble electrical appliances into bizarre contraptions.

star 7.29
17 votes
Directors: Greg Beeman
Writers: Matt Dearborn
The Hole in the Head Gang

#18 - The Hole in the Head Gang

Season 1 - Episode 13

Marshall and Simon investigate an old mill rumored to be haunted. It proves to be a hoax, set up by a mysterious young man who doesn't want anybody nosing around... or so it seems until they accidentally uncover a rusted gun, containing the ghost of Grungy Bill - Eerie's worst bank robber.

star 7.17
18 votes
Directors: Joe Dante
Writers: Karl Schaefer
Mr. Chaney

#19 - Mr. Chaney

Season 1 - Episode 14

Marshall is chosen to be the Eerie ""harvest king"" and must go face the Eerie wolf in the forest. Trouble is - none of the previous harvest kings have ever returned...

star 7.07
14 votes
Directors: Mark Goldblatt
Writers: Jose Rivera