The BEST episodes of Nostalgia Critic season 2

Every episode of Nostalgia Critic season 2, ranked from best to worst by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The best episodes of Nostalgia Critic season 2!

Nostalgia Critic is a popular video series created by Chicago comedian Doug Walker. In the show, he plays the titular Nostalgia Critic, a grumpy and easily aggravated character who mostly reviews entertainment from the 1980s and 1990s. His catch-phrase, "I'm the Nostalgia Critic. I remember it, so you don't have to," usually opens and ends each video.

Last Updated: 4/30/2024Network: YouTubeStatus: Continuing
Share:
Blank Check
star
8.43
7 votes

#1 - Blank Check

Season 2 - Episode 39 - Aired 9/15/2009

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Blank Check, a movie that blandly ripoffs many ideas from other movies, especially Home Alone. He also finds that there is a weird romantic relationship involving a kid, Preston, and Shay, a full grown woman F.B.I. agent. With such a bland movie, the Nostalgia Critic finds it hard to enjoy it.

Cool as Ice
star
8.33
3 votes

#2 - Cool as Ice

Season 2 - Episode 41 - Aired 9/29/2009

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the film Cool as Ice, staring Vanilla Ice in his first and last acting role.

Watch Now:Amazon
Suburban Commando
star
7.67
3 votes

#3 - Suburban Commando

Season 2 - Episode 42 - Aired 10/6/2009

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the sci-fi comedy Suburban Commando, starring Hulk Hogan and talks about how some wrestlers just don't know how to act.

The Next Karate Kid
star
7.67
3 votes

#4 - The Next Karate Kid

Season 2 - Episode 43 - Aired 10/13/2009

The Nostalgia Critic reviews The Next Karate Kid, a film that shows us that the Karate Kid movies have gotten pretty bad over the years.

Captain America
star
7.57
7 votes

#5 - Captain America

Season 2 - Episode 36 - Aired 8/25/2009

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Captain America. However, he finds that this super hero is portrayed like a pushover and always getting beaten.

Alone In The Dark
star
7.50
10 votes

#6 - Alone In The Dark

Season 2 - Episode 38 - Aired 9/8/2009

After being requested to review an Uwe Boll movie, the Nostalgia Critic decides to review Alone in The Dark. However, the movie is so bad that he loses his voice and is forced to use the Macintalk to speak. Just before he's ready to give up, Spoony and Linkara decide to help him review the movie. Will three critics be enough to review an Uwe Boll movie?

Warriors of Virtue
star
7.33
9 votes

#7 - Warriors of Virtue

Season 2 - Episode 35 - Aired 8/18/2009

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Warriors of Virtue. Despite the fact that it promises martial arts and kangaroos, he finds the movie to be incredibly boring.

A Tribute to Siskel and Ebert
star
7.00
1 votes

#8 - A Tribute to Siskel and Ebert

Season 2 - Episode 47 - Aired 11/10/2009

The Nostalgia Critic pays tribute to his favorite critics, Siskel and Ebert. Due to their take on movies and the lasting impression they left on the world, The Nostalgia Critic honors them with a look back at their work.

Star Wars Holiday Special
star
7.00
1 votes

#9 - Star Wars Holiday Special

Season 2 - Episode 53 - Aired 12/22/2009

After failing to believe that such a holiday special existed, the Nostalgia Critic is forced to review the universally hated 1978 Star Wars Holiday Special. With such a Christmas bomb on his hands, has the Nostalgia Critic finally met his match?

He-Man and She-Ra - A Christmas Special
star
6.00
1 votes

#10 - He-Man and She-Ra - A Christmas Special

Season 2 - Episode 51 - Aired 12/8/2009

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the 1985 He-Man and She-Ra: A Christmas Special, based on the He-Man and the Masters of the Universe and She-Ra: Princess of Power animated series. Will two super heroes make this a super special or a super failure?

Ernest Saves Christmas
star
6.00
1 votes

#11 - Ernest Saves Christmas

Season 2 - Episode 54 - Aired 12/29/2009

After surviving the Star Wars Holiday Special, the Nostalgia Critic reviews the 1988 Christmas movie Ernest Saves Christmas. Will this movie make up for the last holiday special, or will it forever sour his view of the Christmas season?

The Return of the Christmas Specials
star
6.00
1 votes

#12 - The Return of the Christmas Specials

Season 2 - Episode 52 - Aired 12/16/2009

It has been one year since the Nostalgia Critic did his Top 12 Christmas Specials. Now he decides to do a Top 11 of all the Christmas specials that he forgot to mention.

Jack Frost
star
6.00
1 votes

#13 - Jack Frost

Season 2 - Episode 50 - Aired 12/1/2009

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the 1998 Christmas film Jack Frost. Will this movie provide Christmas cheer for the Nostalgia Critic, or will its nonsensical story send him into a yuletide rage?

Tank Girl
star
6.00
1 votes

#14 - Tank Girl

Season 2 - Episode 49 - Aired 11/24/2009

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the 1995 movie Tank Girl, based off the comic book series by the same name. However, this poor adaptation was too long and stupid for the Nostalgia Critic to follow.

Judge Dredd
star
6.00
1 votes

#15 - Judge Dredd

Season 2 - Episode 48 - Aired 11/17/2009

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the 1995 action film Judge Dredd starring Sylvester Stallone.

Old VS. New: Batman (1989) vs Dark Knight (2008)
star
0.00
0 votes

#16 - Old VS. New: Batman (1989) vs Dark Knight (2008)

Season 2 - Episode 21 - Aired 5/20/2009

The Nostalgia Critic introduces a new way to review and compare similar movies. This time he compares the original 1989 Batman to the 2008 Dark Knight movie. Which one will emerge as the better Batman movie?

Congo
star
0.00
0 votes

#17 - Congo

Season 2 - Episode 46 - Aired 11/3/2009

The Nostalgia Critc reviews the movie Congo that teaches us the difference between real gorillas and guys in ape costumes.

Full House
star
0.00
0 votes

#18 - Full House

Season 2 - Episode 22 - Aired 5/26/2009

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the show Full House. Despite it being a popular television show, he can't understand how it lasted so long with bland characters and unfunny jokes.

North
star
0.00
0 votes

#19 - North

Season 2 - Episode 23 - Aired 6/3/2009

With the movie North being so widely known as being terrible, even by Siskel and Ebert, the Nostalgia Critic can't help but review it. With unfunny jokes and extremely stereotypical and racist ethnicities being portrayed, perhaps he should have passed this one up.

Critic and Nerd: TMNT Making of Coming Out of Their Shells
star
0.00
0 votes

#20 - Critic and Nerd: TMNT Making of Coming Out of Their Shells

Season 2 - Episode 24 - Aired 6/10/2009

Deciding to put aside their differences and review something together, the Nostalgia Critic and The Angry Video Game Nerd decide to review a documentary about a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles band. However, this movie may be so bad that not even the two of them can handle it.

Sidekicks
star
0.00
0 votes

#21 - Sidekicks

Season 2 - Episode 25 - Aired 6/17/2009

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Sidekicks. With a kid constantly dreaming about Chuck Norris, the film becomes even more self-indulgent than Moonwalker. Can Chuck Norris save the movie from the wrath of the Nostalgia Critic?

Gargoyles
star
0.00
0 votes

#22 - Gargoyles

Season 2 - Episode 26 - Aired 6/24/2009

The Nostalgia Critic salutes the Walt Disney show, Gargoyles.

Transformers 2
star
0.00
0 votes

#23 - Transformers 2

Season 2 - Episode 27 - Aired 6/27/2009

In honor of his first review, the Nostalgia Critic goes back to his original formula for reviewing the latest Transformers movie, Transformers 2.

Steel
star
0.00
0 votes

#24 - Steel

Season 2 - Episode 28 - Aired 7/1/2009

The Nostalgia Critic reviews Steel. With Shaquille O'Neal's wooden acting when trying to portray a super hero, this movie is going to be easy for the Nostalgia Critic to bash.

Top 11 Cereal Mascots
star
0.00
0 votes

#25 - Top 11 Cereal Mascots

Season 2 - Episode 29 - Aired 7/7/2009

If there is one thing that kids know best, it is cereal. So, the Nostalgia Critic counts down the Top 11 cereal mascots.