The BEST episodes of Fantasy Island season 2

Every episode of Fantasy Island season 2, ranked from best to worst by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The best episodes of Fantasy Island season 2!

Smiles everyone, Smiles! So began this long-running (7 season) series which was one of the ABC Network's anthology/guest-cast series (along with The Love Boat) that proved wildly popular. Each week two guests came to "Fantasy Island" to get their wish/fantasy fulfilled. Their mysterious host, the debonair and suave white-suited Mr. Roarke, would do the sometimes impossible and grant them their wishes...but there was always some twist to the fantasy, letting the guest learn something about themselves or get something they weren't expecting. Best remembered for the presence of Herve Villechaize as the diminuitive "Tattoo" and his cry of "De plane! De plane!" the show proved popular enough to go the distance and then spawn a brief revival/remake in the 1990s. A remake, Fantasy Island (1998)in the late 1990's was not as successful as its predecessor. In 2020 it was made into a movie with Michael Pena in the title role.

Last Updated: 9/18/2024Network: ABC (US)Status: Ended
Amusement Park / Rock Stars
star
8.33
3 votes

#1 - Amusement Park / Rock Stars

Season 2 - Episode 25 - Aired 5/13/1979

In "Amusement Park" a boy wants to run the park in order to have the opportunity to hire his dad whom he hasnt seen in a long time. In "Rock Stars" four kids whose parents are believed dead seek fame and fortune to remain a family and not be separated by childrens aid.

Directors: Cliff Bole
Watch Now:Amazon
Charlie's Cherubs / Stalag 3
star
8.00
6 votes

#2 - Charlie's Cherubs / Stalag 3

Season 2 - Episode 12 - Aired 12/9/1978

In "Charlie's Cherubs" three secretaries want to be like their heroines-Charlie's Angels. In "Stalag 3" four World War II veterans relive their days in a German prison camp.

Directors: Cliff Bole
Watch Now:AmazonApple TV
Cowboy / Substitute Wife
star
7.83
6 votes

#3 - Cowboy / Substitute Wife

Season 2 - Episode 15 - Aired 1/20/1979

In "Cowboy" Brian Kehoe complicates a happy reunion by past lies about being a rodeo star when in fact he is only a rodeo clown. In "Substitute Wife" hypochondriac Nadine Winslow seeks a new wife for her husband when she thinks she is dying.

Directors: Arnold Laven
Watch Now:Amazon
Let the Goodtimes Roll / Nightmare / The Tiger
star
7.75
4 votes

#4 - Let the Goodtimes Roll / Nightmare / The Tiger

Season 2 - Episode 7 - Aired 11/4/1978

In "Let the Goodtimes Roll" a former hot-rod king wishes for his past glory and get the girl he left behind. In "Nightmare" Jeanine Sanford has terrifying nightmares which she wants to overcome. In "The Tiger" also known as Jamporie, world famous adventure writer Victor Duncan wants to stalk a legendary wild beast.

Directors: George McCowan
Watch Now:AmazonApple TV
Carnival / The Vaudevillians
star
7.60
5 votes

#5 - Carnival / The Vaudevillians

Season 2 - Episode 11 - Aired 12/2/1978

In "Carnival" a young coma victim believes that the man in her dreams really exists. In "The Vaudevillians" old timers Will Fields and Charlie Parks try their hand at bringing Vaudeville back, escaping exile to a retirement home neither wants.

Watch Now:AmazonApple TV
Bowling / Command Performance
star
7.60
5 votes

#6 - Bowling / Command Performance

Season 2 - Episode 24 - Aired 5/12/1979

In "Bowling" amateur bowler Lou Fielding fulfills his dream of bowling with the world's best bowlers! In "Command Performance" a retire circus owner gathers her old acts together for a 25 year reunion, aware that one of them wants her dead.

Directors: Mike Vejar
Watch Now:Amazon
The Lady and the Longhorn / Vampire
star
7.50
6 votes

#7 - The Lady and the Longhorn / Vampire

Season 2 - Episode 13 - Aired 12/16/1978

In "The Lady and the Longhorn" sweet but wacky businesswoman Vera Templeton is after a millionaire to save her company from bankruptcy. And in "Vampire" famous method actor Leo Drake prepares for his role as Dracula in a very frightening and dangerous way.

Watch Now:AmazonApple TV
Yesterday's Love / Fountain of Youth
star
7.50
4 votes

#8 - Yesterday's Love / Fountain of Youth

Season 2 - Episode 21 - Aired 3/17/1979

In "Yesterday's Love" Peggy and Charles Atwood who are on the brink of divorce after 35 years of marriage, rekindle their love. In "Fountain of Youth" an old man on the brink of death hires a soldier of fortune to take him to the fountain of youth.

Watch Now:Amazon
Cornelius and Alfonse / The Choice
star
7.50
6 votes

#9 - Cornelius and Alfonse / The Choice

Season 2 - Episode 23 - Aired 5/6/1979

In "Cornelius and Alfonse" a couple of petty crooks seeking revenge against Mr. Roarke kidnap Tattoo for ransom. Unaware of what they have gotten themselves into they soon beg Roarke to take Tattoo back. In "The Choice" two orphans are given a chance to choose their adoptive parents to their very own specifications.

Directors: Earl Bellamy
Watch Now:Amazon
The Stripper / The Boxer
star
7.43
7 votes

#10 - The Stripper / The Boxer

Season 2 - Episode 17 - Aired 2/10/1979

In "The Stripper" a rich Daddy's girl decides to become a Burlesque dancer using the name Lulu LaVerne, much to her father's dismay. In "The Boxer" Billy Blake who has a short time to live decides to have one last bout.

Directors: Lawrence Dobkin
Watch Now:Amazon
Pentagram / A Little Ball / Casting Director
star
7.43
7 votes

#11 - Pentagram / A Little Ball / Casting Director

Season 2 - Episode 18 - Aired 2/17/1979

In "Pentagram" TV reporter Jane Garwood becomes an unsuspecting target when her relationships start dying one by one. In "A Little Ball" a nun has to decide between the church and getting married. In "Casting Couch" Felix Birdsong becomes casting director and is overwhelmed when all the lovelies attempt to win the lead role in a movie. Bribs not withstanding Felix is between a rock and a hard place.

Directors: George McCowan
Watch Now:Amazon
Birthday Party / Ghostbreaker
star
7.43
7 votes

#12 - Birthday Party / Ghostbreaker

Season 2 - Episode 20 - Aired 3/3/1979

"Birthday Party" is about a 47-year-old bar and grill owner from Phoenix, AZ (Carol Gates, played by Janet Leigh), who was forced to give up her twins for adoption 30 years prior, right after they were born. Her fantasy was to be reunited with Tom Dearborn and Tracy Miller (the twins) and wish them a happy 30th birthday. "Ghostbreaker" is about a librarian (Elliott Fielding, played by Ken Berry) who wanted to have his book on ghostbreaking published. He doubted any publisher would touch it without ghost exorcising experience behind it, so his fantasy was to banish a ghost. He was taken to the Camberly School for Girls, headed by Edna Camberly (played by Annette Funicello). The school was the home of a killer known as the Gentleman Strangler, and his ghost was terrorizing the students. Through the teamwork of Elliott Fielding and Edna Camberly, the "ghost" was discovered to be Allan LeBlanc (played by Larry Storch), who was trying to swindle the school away from Edna Camberly.

Directors: Cliff Bole
Watch Now:Amazon
Spending Spree / The Hunted
star
7.33
9 votes

#13 - Spending Spree / The Hunted

Season 2 - Episode 19 - Aired 2/24/1979

In "Spending Spree" two girlfriends are given half a million dollars to spend and realize that friendship is more important than anything is. In "The Hunted" a thrill seeking big game hunter unexpectedly becomes the prey in the hunt.

Watch Now:Amazon
Photographs / Royal Flush
star
7.25
8 votes

#14 - Photographs / Royal Flush

Season 2 - Episode 16 - Aired 1/27/1979

In "Photographs" photographer Nancy Weston is haunted by the mysterious image of an unknown girl in her photos. In "Royal Flush" Johnny Court attempts to become the best gambler ousting Victor Holly of his title.

Directors: Cliff Bole
Watch Now:Amazon
War Games / Queen of the Boston Bruisers
star
7.19
36 votes

#15 - War Games / Queen of the Boston Bruisers

Season 2 - Episode 6 - Aired 10/28/1978

In "War Games" a bitter Vietnam veteran challenges a former Army buddy to a deadly competition. Unbeknowst to him, he holds him responsible for his brother's death. In "Queen of the Boston Bruisers" a tough Roller Derby Queen and single mom tries to pass herself off as a real lady to impress her future inlaws and not embarrass her daughter.

Watch Now:Apple TV
The Homecoming / The Sheikh
star
7.17
75 votes

#16 - The Homecoming / The Sheikh

Season 2 - Episode 1 - Aired 9/16/1978

In "The Homecoming" a Vietnam veteran, long presumed dead wishes to be reunited with his family. Realizing that his wife has remarried and his son doesn't know him, he must move on with his life. In "The Sheikh" a middle-aged school teacher wishes to have a harem of beautiful women, but instead becomes the target of an assassination attempt.

Directors: Earl Bellamy
Watch Now:Apple TV
Seance / The Treasure
star
7.14
7 votes

#17 - Seance / The Treasure

Season 2 - Episode 14 - Aired 1/13/1979

In "Seance" Clare Conti still distraught over her brother's suicide learns that her brother was murdered during a seance. In "The Treasure" a happy marriage is placed in jeopardy when the quest for wealth and all the it encompasses places Joe Capos at a crossroads.

The Flight of the Great Yellow Bird / The Island of Lost Women
star
7.13
8 votes

#18 - The Flight of the Great Yellow Bird / The Island of Lost Women

Season 2 - Episode 10 - Aired 11/25/1978

In "The Flight of the Great Yellow Bird" a former professional adventurer is hired by Professor Smith-Myles to go in search of Bigfoot. In "The Island of Lost Women" a girl crazy sailor Barney Shaw wishes to find out if an island of beautiful women really exists.

Directors: Joseph Pevney
Watch Now:Apple TV
Best Seller / The Tomb
star
7.08
40 votes

#19 - Best Seller / The Tomb

Season 2 - Episode 4 - Aired 10/14/1978

In "Best Seller" Barry Hunter desires the limelight as best-selling author and the women throw themselves at him. In "The Tomb" an archeologist and his daughter confront an Egyptian curse.

Directors: George McCowan
Watch Now:Apple TV
I Want to Get Married / The Jewel Thief
star
7.08
40 votes

#20 - I Want to Get Married / The Jewel Thief

Season 2 - Episode 5 - Aired 10/21/1978

In "I Want to Get Married" a woman wants her long-standing marriage shy boyfriend to finally go ahead with their wedding. In "The Jewel Thief" Jordan Montgomery wants to be a famous jewel thief.

Watch Now:Apple TV
The Beachcomber / The Last Whodunit
star
7.03
37 votes

#21 - The Beachcomber / The Last Whodunit

Season 2 - Episode 3 - Aired 9/30/1978

In "The Beachcomber" Charles Preston fed up with the pressures of his life gives it all up to become a carefree beachcomber and winds up in more trouble than he can handle. In "The Last Whodunit" an avid mystery reader decides to solve the case of murder involving the death of her favorite writer.

Directors: George McCowan
Watch Now:Apple TV
Return / The Toughest Man Alive
star
7.00
37 votes

#22 - Return / The Toughest Man Alive

Season 2 - Episode 8 - Aired 11/11/1978

In "Return" lovely Helena Marsh returns to Fantasy Island to proclaim her love for......Mr. Roarke. In "The Toughest Man Alive" an average man becomes a hero and saves the village from Captain Fisk.

Directors: Earl Bellamy
Watch Now:Apple TV
The Comic / The Golden Hour
star
6.83
6 votes

#23 - The Comic / The Golden Hour

Season 2 - Episode 22 - Aired 5/5/1979

In "The Comic" unappreciated comedy writer Jerry Burton longs to become a stand-up comedian like his employer Danny Baker. In "The Golden Hour" crippled Sandy Larson who has been a pen-pal with a prison inmate, looks forward to meeting him for the first time.

Directors: Earl Bellamy
The Big Dipper / The Pirate
star
6.54
46 votes

#24 - The Big Dipper / The Pirate

Season 2 - Episode 2 - Aired 9/23/1978

In "The Big Dipper" a young girl tries to find a normal life with her pick-pocketing father, when a police sergeant shows up in search of her father. In "The Pirate" an eccentric Ted Cavanaugh hopes to win back the love of his ex-wife by playing out a fantasy.

Directors: Earl Bellamy
Watch Now:Apple TV
The Appointment / Mr. Tattoo
star
6.35
37 votes

#25 - The Appointment / Mr. Tattoo

Season 2 - Episode 9 - Aired 11/18/1978

In "The Appointment" Dr. John Carlson who is doctor too busy with business to see his patients, seeks funds to build a computerized health care complex and winds up having to make a life and death decision. In "Mr. Tattoo" Dee Dee and Evelyn enlist Tattoo in helping them find millionaires to marry.

Directors: Cliff Bole
Watch Now:Apple TV