The WORST episodes of Evil Lives Here
Every episode of Evil Lives Here ever, ranked from worst to best by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The worst episodes of Evil Lives Here!
Each hour-long episode of this chilling psychological drama tells the harrowing, firsthand stories of living with a person who became a killer. Viewers will be put in the shoes of the loved one, who lived through this incredible experience —from first noticing that something is amiss, to interpreting all of the puzzling signs and clues, to eventually coming face-to-face with the horrible truth: that the person they loved, the person they trusted, has a very dark side.
#2 - He Fed Them to Gators
Season 10 - Episode 13 - Aired 10/17/2021
Craig Lester Thrift brags about getting away with murder, but everyone thinks he is kidding. Robyn Barry knows Thrift better than anyone, and she begins to suspect he isn't joking. Someone needs to believe her before Thrift makes her his next victim.
Watch Now:Amazon#3 - What If He Gets Out
Season 11 - Episode 2 - Aired 2/27/2022
When Amy Chessler calls 911 to report what her brother, Jesse Winnick, has confessed to, she doesn't know whether to believe him. Jesse's always been a liar, and Amy doesn't truly understand what he is capable of until she walks in and sees it for herself.
Watch Now:Apple TV#4 - He Kept Her in a Tree Stump
Season 11 - Episode 4 - Aired 3/13/2022
After Ernest Christie dies, his son, Sam, calls police and tells them everything he witnessed as a child, including murder. He is finally rid of the secrets he carried for decades, and now may pay a price for helping his father get away with it all.
Watch Now:Apple TV#5 - He Was a False Prophet
Season 11 - Episode 5 - Aired 3/20/2022
As a child, Benjamin Risha believes Tony Alamo when he preaches he is a prophet of God. Although, as Benjamin gets older and realizes that the prophet is a liar, he fears for his life, because he sees what happens to others who doubt Tony.
Watch Now:Apple TV#6 - Keeping My Brother's Secret
Season 11 - Episode 6 - Aired 3/27/2022
When Steven Crittenden confesses to his brother, Bryant, and then swears him to secrecy, Bryant faces the toughest decision of his life: whether to keep the secret and risk letting a murderer get away with it, or tell the truth and betray his family.
Watch Now:Apple TV#7 - She Should Be Left to Die
Season 11 - Episode 7 - Aired 4/3/2022
When police tell Chris Matechen that his girlfriend, Alyssa Dayvault has confessed, he doesn't want to believe it because that means admitting that he has fallen for her lies and spent years blind to the horrific things she did right under his nose.
Watch Now:Apple TV#9 - He Tied Me Up Too
Season 12 - Episode 2 - Aired 7/10/2022
When James Bergstrom's wife, Linda, begins to suspect that his bondage fetish is becoming something more sinister, she can't get anyone to believe her, but the more she learns about his behavior, the more she becomes determined to stop her husband.
Watch Now:Apple TV#10 - He Should Have Died Sooner
Season 12 - Episode 1 - Aired 7/3/2022
When George Yzaguirre kills himself in prison, he takes his secrets with him, and his ex-wife, Jennifer Meyer, is left to wonder how many of her memories might hold the keys to unsolved crimes and whether or not she will ever know the truth about him.
Watch Now:Apple TV#11 - We All Die Tonight
Season 10 - Episode 12 - Aired 10/10/2021
Christina Gaines goes on a date with Patrick Fowler, a supposed "perfect gentleman." She soon discovers Patrick's true nature and realizes she's been duped. Now that Christina is in his grasp, she must find a way to avoid becoming his next victim.
Watch Now:Amazon
#15 - I Watched Daddy Bury Mommy
Season 13 - Episode 1 - Aired 1/22/2023
As a 5-year-old child, Lori Hodge does not understand what she sees when her father, Lyle Eugene Keidel, aka Gene Keidel, digs a hole in the yard in the middle of the night. But as she gets older and realizes the truth, she becomes a threat to her father. He will stop at nothing to keep his dark secrets.
#16 - Scratch My Murderous Itch
Season 13 - Episode 3 - Aired 2/4/2023
Eugene Borg knows that Satan has evil plans for his young son Tyler and spends the subsequent years battling the demons he believes plague his child; a shock comes that proves that he may have forever lost the war for his son's soul.

#17 - I Made It Out Alive
Season 13 - Episode 2 - Aired 1/29/2023
For years, every time Gabi Blair walks past the freezer, she shudders at the thought of the horrors hidden inside; forced to keep secret her mother's crimes, she prays that someone will discover the truth before she becomes her mother's next victim.
#18 - Kill Him, Save Yourself
Season 13 - Episode 4 - Aired 2/19/2023
David Magnano and his stepsister, Jessica, know that Scott Magnano is dangerous; they know they would be safer if he were gone; what David doesn't know is how much he will regret not killing Scott when he has the chance.
#19 - He Called It "The Need"
Season 13 - Episode 5 - Aired 2/26/2023
When Dianne Burns moves across the country to marry Mark Burns in prison, she holds no doubts of her fiancé's wrongful conviction until after his release, when she begins to see signs of both his guilt and plans to resume his criminal behaviour.
#20 - Why Did I Let Him In?
Season 10 - Episode 3 - Aired 8/1/2021
Teshana Singleton initially thinks her first boyfriend Cedric Ricks' obsession with her is flattering, but when his obsession turns evil, she begins to realize she's in danger. Cedric believes if he cannot have Teshana, no one can.
Watch Now:Amazon
#21 - The Horror I Don't Remember
Season 2 - Episode 4 - Aired 1/22/2017
Sherry Shafer never had a good relationship with her younger brother, Brian Britton, but she never expected to lose everything because of him; today, all she has left is the fear that one day he will return to finish what he started 26 years ago.
Watch Now:Amazon#23 - The Hole in the Backyard
Season 13 - Episode 8 - Aired 3/19/2023
When a hole appears in the backyard, Delila Yang gets suspicious; she knows her mother, Karina, dug it and knows someone is missing, but Delila doesn't yet realize she must work with police to trap her mom and unearth her sinister secrets.
Watch Now:Amazon#24 - Ménage à Terror
Season 13 - Episode 9 - Aired 4/2/2023
Genie already knows Lee Cawthon is capable of horrible things when he forces her into a polygamous relationship; she plays along with his twisted demands, but doesn't realize that the consequences of letting him have his way might be worse.
Watch Now:Amazon