The WORST seasons of Are You Afraid of the Dark? (2019)

Every season of Are You Afraid of the Dark? (2019) ever, ranked from worst to best by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The worst seasons of Are You Afraid of the Dark? (2019)!

An anthology series that follows different chapters of the Midnight Society, a group of teenagers who gather at midnight to tell scary stories, such as the Carnival of Doom and the Curse of the Shadows.

Last Updated: 10/29/2024Network: NickelodeonStatus: Ended
Ghost Island
star
6.43
7 votes

#1 - Ghost Island

First Aired 7/30/2022

A group of kids arrives on an island for a summer vacation, only to learn that their resort is haunted by the ghosts of guests who have gone missing over the years. As they uncover the secrets of the island, the mystery puts them all in danger of becoming the next victims of the curse.

Carnival of Doom
star
7.26
31 votes

#2 - Carnival of Doom

First Aired 10/11/2019

Members of the Midnight Society tell a terrifying tale of the Carnival of Doom and its evil ringmaster, Mr. Tophat, only to witness the shocking story come frightfully to life.

Curse of the Shadows
star
7.44
18 votes

#3 - Curse of the Shadows

First Aired 2/13/2021

An all-new Midnight Society group of kids learn of the terrifying curse cast over their small seaside town, and are haunted by a mysterious creature known as the Shadowman.