The BEST Episodes of Are You Afraid of the Dark? (2019)

Every episode ever - ranked by fan votes!

Last Updated: Apr 2, 2021

Network: Nickelodeon

An anthology series that follows different chapters of the Midnight Society, a group of teenagers who gather at midnight to tell scary stories, such as the Carnival of Doom and the Curse of the Shadows.

The Tale of the Darkhouse

#1 - The Tale of the Darkhouse

Season 2 - Episode 6 - Aired Mar 19, 2021

Luke gets help from the beyond to uncover more supernatural secrets, and devises a bold plan to finally end the curse of the shadows. Season finale.

star 8.17
23 votes
Directors: Jeff Wadlow
Writers:
The Tale of the Danse Macabre

#2 - The Tale of the Danse Macabre

Season 2 - Episode 4 - Aired Mar 5, 2021

On the eve of the school dance, the Midnight Society wrestles with the possibility that evil still lurks among them and the nightmare is far from over.

star 8.00
28 votes
Directors: Mathias Herndl
Writers:
The Tale of the Haunted Wood

#3 - The Tale of the Haunted Wood

Season 2 - Episode 1 - Aired Feb 12, 2021

Five kids investigate the disappearance of their friend, the leader of The Midnight Society whose fate may be tied to a mysterious curse that haunts their seaside town.

star 7.65
43 votes
Directors: Jeff Wadlow
Writers:
The Tale of the Midnight Magic

#4 - The Tale of the Midnight Magic

Season 2 - Episode 5 - Aired Mar 12, 2021

With dark forces growing stronger and the curse claiming another victim, a shattered Midnight Society prepares to fight back against the Shadowman.

star 7.63
19 votes
Directors: Jeff Wadlow
Writers:
Part One: Submitted for Approval

#5 - Part One: Submitted for Approval

Season 1 - Episode 1 - Aired Oct 11, 2019

Tormented by a series of scary nightmares, the new girl in school feels isolated and out of place until a mysterious group invites her to join their ranks. All she has to do is tell a truly terrifying story.

star 7.59
125 votes
The Tale of the Night Frights

#6 - The Tale of the Night Frights

Season 2 - Episode 2 - Aired Feb 19, 2021

As the Midnight Society digs deeper into the mystery, they discover themselves haunted by an evil entity known as the Shadowman.

star 7.58
31 votes
Directors: Jeff Wadlow
Writers:
The Tale of the Phantom Light

#7 - The Tale of the Phantom Light

Season 2 - Episode 3 - Aired Feb 26, 2021

star 7.53
30 votes
Directors: Mathias Herndl
Writers:
Part Two: Opening Night

#8 - Part Two: Opening Night

Season 1 - Episode 2 - Aired Oct 18, 2019

When a friend’s disappearance seems to be linked to Rachel’s story, the Midnight Society decides to attend the Carnival of Doom. Is it the same carnival from her nightmares? And if so... how could that be possible?

star 7.42
95 votes
Part Three: Destroy All Tophats

#9 - Part Three: Destroy All Tophats

Season 1 - Episode 3 - Aired Oct 25, 2019

With her friends’ lives at stake, Rachel decides to take charge and end Mr. Tophat’s reign of terror. Will this story have a happy ending... or is the Midnight Society doomed?

star 7.35
79 votes