The BEST episodes of Should I Marry A Murderer?

Every episode of Should I Marry A Murderer? ever, ranked from best to worst by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The best episodes of Should I Marry A Murderer?!

A fiancée becomes a key witness after staying engaged to a man accused of murder to gather evidence against him in this documentary series.

Last Updated: 5/7/2026Network: NetflixStatus: Ended

7.68

19 votes

#1 - Episode 2

Season 1 - Episode 2 - Aired 4/29/2026

As Caroline's actions give police a new lead in a cold case, she enters a terrifying double life with the McKellars — and hopes Sandy still trusts her.

Watch Now:Amazon

7.52

21 votes

#2 - Episode 1

Season 1 - Episode 1 - Aired 4/29/2026

In 2020, a Glasgow pathologist meets a Highland gamekeeper who seems perfect on paper. They're soon engaged — then a confession changes everything.

Watch Now:Amazon

7.25

16 votes

#3 - Episode 3

Season 1 - Episode 3 - Aired 4/29/2026

Torn between doing the right thing and protecting the man she can't walk away from, Caroline spirals as she desperately tries to avoid the witness stand.

Watch Now:Amazon