The BEST episodes of Return to Amish
Every episode of Return to Amish ever, ranked from best to worst by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The best episodes of Return to Amish!
After leaving their sheltered Amish and Mennonite lives, Abe, Jeremiah, Kate, Rebecca and Sabrina experienced New York City together for the first time. Then, they traveled to Sarasota, Florida, in the series Breaking Amish: Brave New World. Now, with the exception of Kate, who’s living in New York and building her modeling career, the group has returned to Pennsylvania, where they take up their old traditions.
#1 - The Black Sheep
Season 6 - Episode 7 - Aired 5/3/2021
After a night of passion with Daniel, Maureen worries about an abnormal itch. Sabrina and Jethro have an emotional face-off. Jeremiah meets his biological cousin. Rosanna goes on her first date.
#2 - Leaving Everything Behind
Season 5 - Episode 1 - Aired 11/18/2018
Mary must decide if she will rejoin the Amish church; Jeremiah and Carmela make a risky decision to save their marriage; Sabrina must prove to Jeremiah that she's changed; Shelly, Lowell and Dawn decide to explore the English world.
#3 - Donut Season
Season 5 - Episode 2 - Aired 11/25/2018
Jeremiah and Carmela introduce Lowell, Shelly, and Dawn to the English world. Drama unfolds between Shelly and Lowell and threatens to ruin everyone's time. How will Sabrina react to news of her father's death? Will the Amish community welcome Mary back?
#4 - Sabrina's Surprise
Season 5 - Episode 3 - Aired 12/2/2018
Lowell, Shelly, and Dawn rebel against Jeremiah's rigid rules and explore the English world; Mary must find a way to please the Bishop; Sabrina tries to make things right with Jeremiah; Jeremiah's temper creates problems.
#5 - Jeremiah's Dark Past
Season 5 - Episode 4 - Aired 12/9/2018
Jeremiah faces challenges as he opens his donut stand for the first time; Mary attends church for the first time since returning home; Shelly debates whether she should contact her biological mother; Dawn wonders about going home.
#6 - Going Full English
Season 5 - Episode 5 - Aired 12/23/2018
Despite initial success with the donut stand, tensions mount between Jeremiah and Carmela; Lowell decides to go Full English with a makeover; Mary must confront an Amish woman speaking out against her to the Bishop; Sabrina works at the donut stand.
#7 - Forgive Me, Carmela
Season 5 - Episode 6 - Aired 12/30/2018
Jeremiah makes a desperate plea for Carmela to return; Dawn and Shelly go full English; Lowell must make a difficult call to his Mennonite parents; Mary takes a risk that could threaten her standing in the Amish community; Sabrina says good-bye.
#8 - Stay Amish or Go English?
Season 5 - Episode 7 - Aired 1/6/2019
Jeremiah and Ada must decide the future of their donut stand business; Mary learns her fate with the Amish Church; Shelly meets her biological mother; Lowell finds out surprising news about his baby during an ultrasound; Dawn reveals a dark secret.
#9 - No Turning Back
Season 5 - Episode 8 - Aired 1/13/2019
Jeremiah, Carmela, Ada, Dawn, and Lowell gather for Shelly's wedding; Shelly hopes that her Mennonite mother will come to her English wedding; Lowell and Lisa prepare for the unexpected arrival of their babies.
#10 - The Panic in Amish Park
Season 6 - Episode 1 - Aired 3/22/2021
The pandemic has forced Jeremiah, Carmela, Ada and Sabrina together.
#11 - The Past Isn't the Past
Season 6 - Episode 2 - Aired 3/29/2021
Ada takes Maureen and Roseanna to the ocean for the first time, but Roseanna contemplates.
#12 - The Time Has Come
Season 6 - Episode 3 - Aired 4/5/2021
While questioning his own father's legitimacy, Jeremiah discusses having a baby with Carmela
#13 - The DNA Test Request
Season 6 - Episode 4 - Aired 4/12/2021
After hours alone in labor, Sabrina must have an emergency C-section. Roseanna has had enough of hearing about Maureen's new beau. Still having doubts about his biological father, Jeremiah asks Dennis to take a DNA test.
#14 - The Truth About Jeremiah's Dad
Season 6 - Episode 5 - Aired 4/19/2021
Jeremiah learns the truth about his father. Rosanna and Maureen buy their first bathing suits, but then they learn...
#15 - The Most Awkward First Kiss Ever
Season 6 - Episode 6 - Aired 4/26/2021
While out with new friends, Rosanna gets asked out on a date. Maureen has her first kiss, but she has reservations about going further. Jeremiah meets his biological cousin. Jethro walks out on Sabrina and their kids.
#16 - Amish Pair-O-Dice
Season 4 - Episode 6 - Aired 6/4/2017
Mary takes Jeremiah and Carmela to Las Vegas for the honeymoon they never had, but a fight between Abe and Jeremiah threatens the trip; Mary brings the family together for Jeremiah and Carmela's vow renewal; Rebecca and Sabrina come face to face.
#17 - The Family Resemblance
Season 6 - Episode 8 - Aired 5/10/2021
Maureen and Rosanna must decide to go English or stay Amish. Jeremiah comes face-to-face with his biological cousins for the first time. While Sabrina is trying to salvage her relationship with Jethro, others are slower to absolve him of his sins.
#18 - The Last Time You See Your Family
Season 6 - Episode 9 - Aired 5/17/2021
Maureen's Amish parents deliver a blow, but she feels support from Daniel. Rosanna realizes that her decision to leave the Amish community will affect everyone in her family. Sabrina wrestles with whether Jethro will fall back into his old ways.
#19 - The English Makeover
Season 6 - Episode 10 - Aired 5/24/2021
Ada throws a party to celebrate Maureen and Rosanna's English makeovers. When Jeremiah reveals he wants to be a father, Carmela's answer could make or break their marriage. Sabrina and Jethro try to fix their relationship, but a secret changes everything.
#20 - Karma Carmela Chameleon
Season 7 - Episode 1 - Aired 3/14/2023
Ada hopes Maureen will join her in Florida; Jeremiah and Carmela get away from the stress of baby-making; Rosanna must choose between her Amish boyfriend or the English life; Jethro has left Sabrina while she is pregnant with their third child.
#21 - Daniel, My Brother
Season 7 - Episode 2 - Aired 3/21/2023
Johnny panics when he goes to an English nightclub for the first time; Jeremiah and Carmela help Sabrina with a medical scare; Daniel makes a date with an English girl; Kenneth arrives in Florida to pursue his dreams of playing basketball.
#22 - Fannie, Are You OK?
Season 7 - Episode 3 - Aired 3/28/2023
Jethro comes back to make amends with Sabrina; Kenneth tests his basketball skills; Rosanna's older brother learns about her sleeping arrangements; facing being shunned, Fannie flees to Florida only to be dropped in the middle of more drama.
#23 - Come On, Maureen
Season 7 - Episode 4 - Aired 4/4/2023
Rosanna's brother accuses Ada of eroding the Amish values in the house; Jeremiah wants to apologize to Dennis; Fannie has a traumatic beach experience; Maureen confides in Sabrina; Johnny becomes angry when Rosanna models a bikini in public.
#24 - Meet You All the Way, Rosanna Rosanna
Season 7 - Episode 5 - Aired 4/11/2023