The BEST Episodes of Return to Amish

Every episode ever - ranked by fan votes!

Last Updated: Jan 23, 2021

Network: TLC

After leaving their sheltered Amish and Mennonite lives, Abe, Jeremiah, Kate, Rebecca and Sabrina experienced New York City together for the first time. Then, they traveled to Sarasota, Florida, in the series Breaking Amish: Brave New World. Now, with the exception of Kate, who’s living in New York and building her modeling career, the group has returned to Pennsylvania. Abe and Rebecca, still adjusting to married life, prepare to welcome a new baby into the family. Sabrina is also pregnant, but without the support of her Mennonite family, she’s on a difficult journey. Jeremiah has become an entrepreneur of sorts -- and is chasing love. Mary, Abe’s mother, struggles with being shunned by the community, and as her son Andrew is released from jail, he tries to start fresh with his on-again, off-again girlfriend Chapel and to mend his relationship with his family.

Licence to Wed

#1 - Licence to Wed

Season 3 - Episode 8 - Aired Aug 28, 2016

star 8.23
43 votes
The Shunning Truth

#2 - The Shunning Truth

Season 1 - Episode 8 - Aired Jul 20, 2014

Hosted by Michelle Beadle, a revealing reunion looking into the lives of each person and finding out what they have been up to since the show.

star 8.00
19 votes
From Here to Maternity

#3 - From Here to Maternity

Season 4 - Episode 4 - Aired May 21, 2017

Tensions settle down as everyone makes up in Florida; Jeremiah and Carmela meet with a specialist to see if they're able to have a baby; Mary throws Sabrina a baby shower; Sabrina goes into labor a month early.

star 7.94
67 votes
You Lie!

#4 - You Lie!

Season 3 - Episode 4 - Aired Jul 31, 2016

Sabrina overcomes nerves to speak in front of a college class; tension escalates between Rebecca and Sabrina; Esther makes a deal to experience English life.

star 7.93
45 votes
Amish Pair-O-Dice

#5 - Amish Pair-O-Dice

Season 4 - Episode 6 - Aired Jun 4, 2017

Mary takes Jeremiah and Carmela to Las Vegas for the honeymoon they never had, but a fight between Abe and Jeremiah threatens the trip; Mary brings the family together for Jeremiah and Carmela's vow renewal; Rebecca and Sabrina come face to face.

star 7.80
46 votes
Stay Amish or Go English?

#6 - Stay Amish or Go English?

Season 5 - Episode 7 - Aired Jan 6, 2019

star 7.80
10 votes
Shunned & the City

#7 - Shunned & the City

Season 1 - Episode 2 - Aired Jun 8, 2014

Mary takes a trip to New York City with Kate and Katie Ann, who's excited to meet one of the locals. Meanwhile, in Pennsylvania, Abe, Rebecca, Sabrina and Jeremiah discuss having babies and the practice of shunning; and Andrew and Chapel schedule an important appointment.

star 7.76
17 votes
Breaking Dad

#8 - Breaking Dad

Season 3 - Episode 5 - Aired Aug 7, 2016

Mary makes an Amish meal to bring everyone together and make peace; Jeremiah spends time with his kids in New York City; Rebecca and Abe discuss her job at the bakery; Sabrina goes on a special date.

star 7.69
51 votes
Brother, Where Art Thou?

#9 - Brother, Where Art Thou?

Season 1 - Episode 5 - Aired Jun 29, 2014

The Schmucker family meets Abe and Rebecca's newborn baby; Sabrina's pregnancy takes a scary turn; Mary and Chester argue about the church; Chapel receives some news.

star 7.68
22 votes
I'm Amish, What Are You?

#10 - I'm Amish, What Are You?

Season 1 - Episode 3 - Aired Jun 15, 2014

The Schmucker family meets Abe and Rebecca's newborn baby; Sabrina's pregnancy takes a scary turn; Mary and Chester argue about the church; Chapel receives some news.

star 7.63
24 votes
Six More Weeks of Winter

#11 - Six More Weeks of Winter

Season 1 - Episode 4 - Aired Jun 22, 2014

The Schmucker family meets Abe and Rebecca’s newborn baby; Sabrina’s pregnancy takes a scary turn; Mary and Chester argue about the church; Chapel receives some news.

star 7.60
25 votes
The Announcement

#12 - The Announcement

Season 3 - Episode 7 - Aired Aug 21, 2016

star 7.59
49 votes
Mother Schmucker's B&B

#13 - Mother Schmucker's B&B

Season 2 - Episode 4 - Aired Jun 21, 2015

star 7.52
21 votes
Chasing Raber

#14 - Chasing Raber

Season 4 - Episode 5 - Aired May 28, 2017

Mary supports Sabrina at a custody hearing for her newborn baby; Carmela leaves Jeremiah after an explosive argument; Rebecca takes her GED test and is shocked by Abe's reaction.

star 7.51
88 votes
Home Is Where the Beef Is

#15 - Home Is Where the Beef Is

Season 1 - Episode 1 - Aired Jun 1, 2014

The "Breaking Amish" cast—Abe, Jeremiah, Kate, Rebecca and Sabrina—are together again in this reality series, which begins witha holiday dinner at Mary's that doesn't proceed as planned. Meanwhile, Andrew has a score to settle with Jeremiah after getting out of jail; Rebecca and Sabrina discuss their pregnancies; and Kate waits for news about an exciting opportunity.

star 7.45
49 votes
Banished

#16 - Banished

Season 3 - Episode 2 - Aired Jul 17, 2016

star 7.45
47 votes
Other Side of the Fence

#17 - Other Side of the Fence

Season 2 - Episode 5 - Aired Jun 28, 2015

star 7.43
23 votes
A Secret

#18 - A Secret

Season 2 - Episode 6 - Aired Jul 5, 2015

star 7.42
24 votes
Mary With Children

#19 - Mary With Children

Season 4 - Episode 1 - Aired Apr 30, 2017

In the season premiere, Sabrina is in a new battle for custody of Oakley while dealing with her pregnancy; Jeremiah and Carmela plan to build a home in Florida; Rebecca wants to go back to school; and Mary learns sad news about her father.

star 7.39
66 votes
Fun in the Shun

#20 - Fun in the Shun

Season 4 - Episode 3 - Aired May 14, 2017

Jeremiah needs alone time with Carmela to help their marriage; Rebecca's arrival in Florida creates upheaval for everyone's vacation; Sabrina learns the fate of her parental rights to Oakley and worries that her newborn child will also be taken.

star 7.39
66 votes
Under Arrest

#21 - Under Arrest

Season 2 - Episode 2 - Aired Jun 7, 2015

Chapel finds the courage to confront Mary, but her poor health finally catches up with her; Mary's dream of running a Bed and Breakfast.

star 7.39
31 votes
Rebels Without a Claus

#22 - Rebels Without a Claus

Season 3 - Episode 6 - Aired Aug 14, 2016

An Old Christmas celebration brings the cast back to Pennsylvania. Meanwhile, Kate gets bad news about her internship; and dinner is interrupted by a confrontation between Jeremiah and Kate.

star 7.37
59 votes
Ultimatum

#23 - Ultimatum

Season 2 - Episode 7 - Aired Jul 12, 2015

star 7.35
20 votes
Second Chances

#24 - Second Chances

Season 1 - Episode 7 - Aired Jul 13, 2014

Nothing runs smoothly on Andrew and Chapel's big day. Jeremiah makes a final commitment, Abe is worried about the days festivities and Rebecca shares some important advice.

star 7.33
24 votes
No Turning Back

#25 - No Turning Back

Season 5 - Episode 8 - Aired Jan 13, 2019

star 7.33
12 votes