The WORST episodes of I Am a Killer

Every episode of I Am a Killer ever, ranked from worst to best by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The worst episodes of I Am a Killer!

Death row inmates, convicted of capital murder, give a firsthand account of their crimes in this documentary series.

Last Updated: 1/12/2025Network: NetflixStatus: Continuing

6.04

23 votes

#1 - If Things Were Different

Season 5 - Episode 4 - Aired 10/16/2024

Ezdeth Highley reflects on her murder conviction, her transition while being incarcerated and what she's learned during her ongoing 60-year sentence.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.17

42 votes

#2 - Friendly Fire

Season 4 - Episode 6 - Aired 12/21/2022

After fatally shooting a coworker, Thomas "TJ" Schifferns maintains his innocence. But details surrounding the crime suggest TJ had a motive.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.29

14 votes

#3 - A Mother's Choice (2)

Season 6 - Episode 2 - Aired 1/8/2025

As Daniel maintains his innocence, more details about Jose Menchaca's murder come to light, shifting the focus to Candie's troubled past and cartel ties.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.36

50 votes

#4 - Family Matters

Season 4 - Episode 1 - Aired 12/21/2022

A murderer recounts the crime that ended one life and ruined his own. Those affected, including a police officer and the victim's family, also speak.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.45

53 votes

#5 - Someone Else

Season 3 - Episode 2 - Aired 8/30/2022

On death row for murder, Deryl Madison reflects on his struggles with mental illness and finds support from an anti-capital punishment advocate.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.50

28 votes

#6 - Lost Innocence

Season 5 - Episode 2 - Aired 10/16/2024

Young love takes a dark turn when Ashley Morrison's plan to run away with her boyfriend, Christian Sims, results in the murder of his grandmother.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.52

44 votes

#7 - Serving Time

Season 4 - Episode 3 - Aired 12/21/2022

Years after leaving the military, Toby Gregory claims his service and PTSD caused him to murder his wife, Inez. But Inez's family believes otherwise.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.53

30 votes

#8 - Redemption

Season 5 - Episode 1 - Aired 10/16/2024

By helping his fellow inmates, Jamel Hatcher feels he's turned his life around — but not everyone believes his rehabilitation is genuine.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.57

14 votes

#9 - A Mother's Choice (1)

Season 6 - Episode 1 - Aired 1/8/2025

A botched drug deal is only the beginning when Candie Dominguez assists her boyfriend, Daniel Lopez, in his gruesome killing of her cousin.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.60

20 votes

#10 - Loved To Death

Season 5 - Episode 5 - Aired 10/16/2024

Convicted for killing his grandmother, Rex Groves insists he no longer holds murderous thoughts towards his family. But their trust isn't easily won.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.61

49 votes

#11 - Blackout

Season 3 - Episode 4 - Aired 8/30/2022

James Walker claims he has no recollection of the 2001 murder he confessed to committing. An investigation into his traumatic past offers more context.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.64

44 votes

#12 - A Father's Shadow

Season 4 - Episode 4 - Aired 12/21/2022

Enraged over his rebellious daughter's choice in men, an extremist father enlists his son in a terrifying plot of intimidation and murder.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.64

58 votes

#13 - A Question of Loyalty

Season 3 - Episode 1 - Aired 8/30/2022

Subjected to abuse throughout her life, Victoria Smith confessed to killing her husband. But someone close to the case has doubts about her admission.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.65

49 votes

#14 - Rolling the Dice

Season 3 - Episode 5 - Aired 8/30/2022

Accept a plea deal or go to trial? Three men receive radically different prison sentences for their roles in the fatal shooting of a cab driver.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.69

42 votes

#15 - A Mother’s Love

Season 4 - Episode 2 - Aired 12/21/2022

In prison for killing her husband, a woman details her past abuse and her turbulent marriage. Her mother also reflects on their strained relationship.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.73

48 votes

#16 - History Repeating

Season 3 - Episode 3 - Aired 8/30/2022

Daniel Paulsrud says his fatal shooting of partner Leslie was an accident. But accounts from her family - and his handwritten notes - raise doubts.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.78

45 votes

#17 - The Bogeyman

Season 4 - Episode 5 - Aired 12/21/2022

Sentenced to life without parole for Jason Johnson's horrific murder, Gary Black says he has no regrets, while Jason's family finds purpose in tragedy.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.81

16 votes

#18 - A Brutal Outcome

Season 5 - Episode 6 - Aired 10/16/2024

Makueeyapee Whitford claims the murder he committed was an act of self-defense against a rival tribe, but eyewitness testimonies tell a different story.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.83

23 votes

#19 - Lives Lost

Season 5 - Episode 3 - Aired 10/16/2024

Higinio Gonzalez killed a store clerk during an armed robbery at the age of 16. He swears it was an accident, but one county attorney isn't so sure.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.93

45 votes

#20 - A Bad Day

Season 3 - Episode 6 - Aired 8/30/2022

David Cameron Keith recalls the day he took a young hostage before heading to an airport and killing the pilot who volunteered to take the child's place.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.98

59 votes

#21 - Pyro Joe

Season 2 - Episode 6 - Aired 11/5/2019

After slashing the throat of 72-year-old Ruth Predmore when he went to rob her home to pay for his sister’s medical bills, Joseph Murphy spent 24 years on death row before finally having his sentence commuted by the then Governor of Ohio, John Kasich a week ahead of his scheduled execution.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.98

59 votes

#22 - Crossing the Line

Season 2 - Episode 8 - Aired 11/26/2019

Cavona Flenoy was convicted of the murder of a Sudanese student, with prosecutors arguing that she had lured him in with a promise of sex before shooting him and stealing his wallet and car.

Watch Now:Amazon

6.98

60 votes

#23 - Something Hideous

Season 2 - Episode 10 - Aired 12/17/2019

In 1984, alongside two female accomplices, Toby Lynn Williams robbed and kidnapped at gunpoint his former employer, Johnny Moore, his wife, Deborah, and six-month-old baby.

Watch Now:Amazon Apple TV

6.99

73 votes

#24 - Overkill

Season 2 - Episode 2 - Aired 11/19/2019

In 1996, David Barnett murdered his adoptive grandparents, stabbing them over 20 times with five different knives. His motivation for doing so remained a mystery until it was discovered that David Barnett claimed to have been subjected to years of physical and sexual abuse, not by his grandparents but by their son, his adoptive father, John Barnett.

Watch Now:Amazon

7.03

93 votes

#25 - Family Affair

Season 1 - Episode 7 - Aired 7/10/2018

High on a drug that fuels his paranoia, Deandra Buchanan fatally shoots his aunt, stepfather and girlfriend - a crime he claims he can't recall.

Watch Now:Amazon