The BEST episodes of FBoy Island

Every episode of FBoy Island ever, ranked from best to worst by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The best episodes of FBoy Island!

Three women move to a tropical island where they’re joined by 24 men – 12 self-proclaimed “Nice Guys” looking for love, and 12 self-proclaimed “FBoys,” there to compete for cold, hard cash. Hosted by hit comedian and actress Nikki Glaser, the series is a social experiment that asks the age-old question: Can FBoys truly reform or do Nice Guys always finish last?

Last Updated: 5/19/2024Network: The CWStatus: Continuing
Share:
F, Marry, Ghost
star
7.82
17 votes

#1 - F, Marry, Ghost

Season 3 - Episode 6 - Aired 11/10/2023

Douchetank returns but leaves a mess of emotions and accusations on the island! When the Fboys think they've perfected a game of sabotage, they leave the Ladies anxious to eliminate. FBoy, FBye!

The Secrets Are Out
star
7.71
7 votes

#2 - The Secrets Are Out

Season 3 - Episode 8 - Aired 11/24/2023

After a dramatic FBoy status reveal, the ladies go on awkward group dates with their guys to figure out if they can trust them with their hearts. Katie is brought to tears as she struggles with her decision of who to take into the final two.

Watch Now:Amazon
This is Gonna Be a Good Season
star
7.65
20 votes

#3 - This is Gonna Be a Good Season

Season 3 - Episode 1 - Aired 10/16/2023

Hali, Daniella, and former Bachelorette Katie meet the Fboys and Nice Guys, who battle it out to make the strongest first impressions. An unexpected announcement has the guys on edge.

Game Over
star
7.65
17 votes

#4 - Game Over

Season 3 - Episode 4 - Aired 10/30/2023

An Fboy makes a stunning announcement that sends shockwaves throughout the house. As the Ladies start to develop feelings, the FBoys and the Nice Guys are forced to scramble to stay in the game.

Watch Now:Amazon
You're Joking, Right?
star
7.62
21 votes

#5 - You're Joking, Right?

Season 3 - Episode 7 - Aired 11/17/2023

The oven gets set to broil as cupcakes go missing and tensions flair. The women try to weed out more FBoys, but the game takes a revealing turn and hearts get broken.

You're Goofy
star
7.50
36 votes

#6 - You're Goofy

Season 2 - Episode 3 - Aired 7/14/2022

As fresh meat joins the competition, Mia and Tamaris test new waters while still thinking about their other suitors – and Louise’s date raises further questions about one of hers. Then, another FBoy alum blows the competition wide open.

I Was A Piece of Sh*t
star
7.49
37 votes

#7 - I Was A Piece of Sh*t

Season 2 - Episode 6 - Aired 7/21/2022

After Nikki grants access to men’s social media pages, will the ladies want to continue sliding into any of their DMs?

Bro Stole My Eggs
star
7.47
19 votes

#8 - Bro Stole My Eggs

Season 3 - Episode 3 - Aired 10/23/2023

From suds to dud, a foam party takes a turn with the arrival of 3 new competitors. Katie and Vince's relationship is tested, while Daniella runs towards Love. Hali receives some shocking news and fights her way through an explosive Elimination.

Most Vulnerable Player
star
7.47
15 votes

#9 - Most Vulnerable Player

Season 3 - Episode 9 - Aired 12/1/2023

Nikki frees the eliminated guys from Limbro to Mansplain! The ladies are shocked at what they hear, leaving their top two in jeopardy heading into the finale.

I Know You Love You
star
7.40
20 votes

#10 - I Know You Love You

Season 3 - Episode 5 - Aired 11/3/2023

After Hali, Katie, and Daniella send home three nice guys, Nikki surprises them with a deep dive into their social media secrets. The Fboys begin to spiral as the Ladies press them for honest answers.

Watch Now:Amazon
Kiss That Yogurt
star
7.31
29 votes

#11 - Kiss That Yogurt

Season 2 - Episode 7 - Aired 7/28/2022

After all the contestants are revealed as nice guys or Fboys, the ladies put them through a brutal game of “Truth or Burn.”

Man-Cision
star
7.29
35 votes

#12 - Man-Cision

Season 2 - Episode 9 - Aired 8/4/2022

Before the ladies and their final men embark on highly anticipated 24-hour dates, they must first endure “Mansplain,” where secrets are revealed, grievances are aired… and one of Louise’s men is propositioned by an eliminated contestant?

I Was Just Playing the Game
star
7.24
17 votes

#13 - I Was Just Playing the Game

Season 3 - Episode 10 - Aired 12/8/2023

After their final mega-dates, Daniella, Hali and Katie must choose between their final two and decide their own F-ates. Will they finally find love, or will they lose the money and their honey?

Sleepless in the Villa
star
7.23
43 votes

#14 - Sleepless in the Villa

Season 1 - Episode 4 - Aired 8/5/2021

Garrett works to earn back Sarah’s trust after a shocking reveal – which also has unintended consequences on CJ and Casey’s relationship. Then, an epic dance-off gives the ladies a chance to explore connections with the remaining suitors.

Directors: Michael Shea
6'3 Down Under
star
7.20
40 votes

#15 - 6'3 Down Under

Season 2 - Episode 2 - Aired 7/14/2022

When one of the dates takes place a little too close to the house, tension among the guys rivals the heat from the beach. Then, Mercedes gambles with his future as he plots intricate schemes.

Watch Now:Amazon
There's Something About Nakia
star
7.16
43 votes

#16 - There's Something About Nakia

Season 1 - Episode 5 - Aired 8/5/2021

With the pool suddenly narrowed, the remaining hopefuls face a series of hard-hitting questions to test how well they really know the ladies. But as the competition heats up, so does the feud brewing between two of the contestants.

Directors: Michael Shea
Watch Now:Amazon
I Did Not Say That
star
7.14
37 votes

#17 - I Did Not Say That

Season 2 - Episode 4 - Aired 7/21/2022

After a revealing game of “Douche Tank,” no amount of bro-ga could cut the tension as Tamaris calls the comments of one of her suitors into question. Then, the first double elimination sends six guys packing.

FBoy, FBye!
star
7.11
38 votes

#18 - FBoy, FBye!

Season 1 - Episode 10 - Aired 8/12/2021

With a chance at true love – and $100,000 – on the line, Nakia, CJ, and Sarah seal their fate in a jaw-dropping final elimination round to decide who will accompany them off FBoy Island.

Directors: Michael Shea
Do You Like Cats?
star
7.05
38 votes

#19 - Do You Like Cats?

Season 2 - Episode 1 - Aired 7/14/2022

After judging the men’s flex-ability, Mia, Louise, and Tamaris hand out VIP badges to the highly anticipated first party: Brochella. Then, the competition is rocked by the return of a familiar face.

How Sarah Got Her Groove Back
star
7.00
42 votes

#20 - How Sarah Got Her Groove Back

Season 1 - Episode 6 - Aired 8/5/2021

After the suitors’ true colors and social media pages are exposed, Sarah issues an ultimatum, CJ gives someone new a shot, and Nakia returns to her comfort zone.

Directors: Michael Shea
The Men Have No Idea
star
6.91
35 votes

#21 - The Men Have No Idea

Season 2 - Episode 10 - Aired 8/4/2022

After returning from their second 24-hour date, Mia, Louise, and Tamaris must decide which of their final two is really “the one” – until a surprise twist at elimination threatens to change everything.

Watch Now:Amazon
Tom's Journal
star
6.91
32 votes

#22 - Tom's Journal

Season 2 - Episode 8 - Aired 7/28/2022

Now that only a few guys remain, it’s the perfect time for a three-way… date. But who will survive the final elimination?

50 Shades of Nice
star
6.87
39 votes

#23 - 50 Shades of Nice

Season 1 - Episode 9 - Aired 8/12/2021

After the eliminated men return once more to spill the last of the tea on the remaining suitors, the ladies go on the first of their two 24-hour mega-dates… while those left behind hope they’re not being edged out of the competition.

Directors: Michael Shea
Watch Now:Amazon
I Heard You Were a Snake
star
6.86
36 votes

#24 - I Heard You Were a Snake

Season 2 - Episode 5 - Aired 7/21/2022

An unexpected rap battle finds some men flowing – and others flailing – but will anything top the epic bromance that ensues?

Sex, Lies and Selfies
star
6.83
47 votes

#25 - Sex, Lies and Selfies

Season 1 - Episode 3 - Aired 7/29/2021

A bro-down showdown ensues after three new suitors arrive and vie for lost time – and the women’s attention. But just when CJ, Sarah, and Nakia think they’ve figured out the competition, elimination throws everyone for a loop.

Directors: Michael Shea
Watch Now:Amazon