The BEST episodes of Baby Daddy season 1

Every episode of Baby Daddy season 1, ranked from best to worst by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The best episodes of Baby Daddy season 1!

A 20-something bachelor bartender becomes an unlikely parent when an ex-girlfriend leaves a baby girl on his doorstep.

Last Updated: 3/23/2025Network: FreeformStatus: Ended
Something Borrowed, Something Ben
star
7.62
384 votes

#1 - Something Borrowed, Something Ben

Season 1 - Episode 10 - Aired 8/29/2012

Riley is in full Maid of Honor mode as she counts down the days to Katie’s wedding. Ben is convinced that the wedding is going to be boring, and so invites troublemaker, Gene to spice things up. The morning after the rehearsal dinner, Ben wakes up to find Katie in his bed and neither he or Katie can remember how she got there!

Directors: Michael Lembeck
Watch Now:Amazon
Guys, Interrupted
star
7.56
432 votes

#2 - Guys, Interrupted

Season 1 - Episode 4 - Aired 7/18/2012

Bonnie spends all her time with Emma, disrupting the boys' routine. Riley goes on a date with fellow law student, Jack, and Danny has a hard time pretending he doesn't care.

Directors: Michael Lembeck
Writer: Nancy Cohen
Watch Now:Amazon
I Told You So
star
7.55
696 votes

#3 - I Told You So

Season 1 - Episode 2 - Aired 6/27/2012

Miscommunication between Ben and the guys causes their "foolproof" baby-sitting schedule for Emma to fall apart. Ben, feeling his first parental gut wrenching scare that he could have lost his child, realizes he needs to get his act together to really become a good parent to Emma.

Directors: Michael Lembeck
Watch Now:Amazon
Married to the Job
star
7.54
414 votes

#4 - Married to the Job

Season 1 - Episode 5 - Aired 7/25/2012

When Ben hears of an open management position at the bar, he enlists Riley's help to prove to the owner, Henderson, that he's responsible enough for the job. Tucker and Danny exchange the super-girly stroller Bonnie bought for a much cooler one - one that seems to be a total girl magnet.

Directors: Michael Lembeck
Writer: Lester Lewis
Watch Now:Amazon
A Wheeler Family Christmas Outing
star
7.53
318 votes

#5 - A Wheeler Family Christmas Outing

Season 1 - Episode 9 - Aired 8/22/2012

Ben tries to bring everyone together for Emma's first Christmas photo - including his dad, Ray, who is keeping a surprising secret from Bonnie and the boys. Riley and Tucker find Danny's journal from high school, and Riley tries to figure out who he had a crush on.

Directors: Michael Lembeck
Writer: Lester Lewis
Watch Now:Amazon
The Daddy Whisperer
star
7.47
401 votes

#6 - The Daddy Whisperer

Season 1 - Episode 8 - Aired 8/15/2012

Before Izzy agrees to let Ben join her elite "Mommy and Me" class, she offers to meet one-on-one to help him clean up his act. Tucker and Danny set up a man cave in the laundry room. Bonnie and Riley go shopping, but Emma gets too grabby with the merchandise and the girls are held for shoplifting.

Directors: Michael Lembeck
Watch Now:Amazon
May the Best Friend Win
star
7.40
414 votes

#7 - May the Best Friend Win

Season 1 - Episode 7 - Aired 8/8/2012

Ben and Tucker put their friendship to the side when they compete for the heart of the same woman they met at a concert, Ava. Danny is asked to give a speech in front of his team, but is nervous, so Riley gives him public-speaking advice. Bonnie creates a profile on a online dating website.

Directors: Michael Lembeck
Watch Now:Amazon
The Nurse and the Curse
star
7.38
576 votes

#8 - The Nurse and the Curse

Season 1 - Episode 3 - Aired 7/11/2012

Ben and Emma's nurse have a connection; Bonnie and Tucker destroy Danny's good-luck charm.

Directors: Michael Lembeck
Watch Now:Amazon
Take Her Out of the Ballgame
star
7.36
361 votes

#9 - Take Her Out of the Ballgame

Season 1 - Episode 6 - Aired 8/1/2012

After winning their first game, Ben's softball team votes for Riley to replace Ben as team captain. Riley takes the role much too seriously, and the team asks Ben to set things right. Danny learns that Bonnie is dating his hockey coach and plots to break them up.

Directors: Arlene Sanford
Writer: Mark Amato
Watch Now:Amazon
Pilot
star
7.30
876 votes

#10 - Pilot

Season 1 - Episode 1 - Aired 6/20/2012

Ben Wheeler, a bartender in his 20s discovers he's a father when Emma, a baby girl, is left on his apartment doorstep by his ex-girlfriend Angela. Ben decides to give parenting a shot with the help of his friends and family.

Directors: Michael Lembeck
Watch Now:Amazon